Guilty!
Not Guilty
i couldn't care less
di kaya decoy tatics lang ng defense yung bribe daw ng palace sa mga senador? di kaya sila yung totoong nang bribe ng mga senators?remember...di lang ang career ni thief justice nakataya dito...ang totoong nakataya dito ang future at kayamanan ni pandak.
you're right bro. Art. VIII in relation to Rule 65 of the Rules of Court.
RULE 65
Certiorari, Prohibition and Mandamus
Section 1. Petition for certiorari. — When any tribunal, board or officer exercising judicial or quasi-judicial functions has acted without or in excess its or his jurisdiction, or with grave abuse of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction, and there is no appeal, or any plain, speedy, and adequate remedy in the ordinary course of law, a person aggrieved thereby may file a verified petition in the proper court, alleging the facts with certainty and praying that judgment be rendered annulling or modifying the proceedings of such tribunal, board or officer, and granting such incidental reliefs as law and justice may require.
Even if the Impeachment Court would render a judgement of conviction against the Chief Justice, the latter could file a petition for review under rule 65 of the rules of Court in relation to Article VIII of the 1987 Phil. Constitution, and the SC has the power to review the proceedings/decisions of the Impeachment Court when there is a grave of discretion amounting to lack or excess of jurisdiction on the part of the latter.
Hindi maganda ginagawa nitong si Brenda.
Kahit siguro may pagkukulang itong prosecution, her behavior towards Tupas is uncalled for & unparliamentary. Ni-lectureran pa siya in public & this is grandstanding at its worst.
Di ba pwedeng i-admonish ni Manong Johny itong si Brenda?
She'd be a national embarrassment, kung ganyan din siya sa International Court of Justice.![]()
Last edited by chua_riwap; February 14th, 2012 at 06:09 AM.
Brenda likes to brag and show to everyone that she's intellectually superior to anybody..
She's always been like that ever since.
It will be interesting to see if she will still carry that attitude into the International court.
I can almost imagine her berating prosecutors in the int'l courts... hehe
She will be a national embarrassment pag naka upo na sa ICJ.
Si manong jhony naman eh uminom sya ng gamot para sa memory nya. Labo-labo ang session kahapon to the point na nag invoke ng point of order si Sen. Escudero dahil Enrille is accusing the prosecution na wala naman daw silang evidence. Eh yung prosecution ang nagpa subpoena ng mga bank documents manong.
Very disturbing yung mga pinakita nya kahapon. He was at one point claiming na wala syang pinalabas na subpoena para sa Manager ng PSBank at bakit sila pa daw ang naghahanap ng witness.
Mga Judges mo ang nag patawag dyan manong! Satisfied na ang prosecution sa testimony ng president ng PSBank kaya di na nila kailangan ang Manager ng PSbank.
mag explain today sila Tupaz regarding the alleged false documents.
Nakakatawa yang argument na yan dahil the court will only subpoena the details of bank account numbers. Enrile will not allow a subpoena stating all bank accounts of CJ.
Now granting the prosecution don't have those documents but knows the bank account numbers of CJ, sasabihin nanaman ng korte. Pano mo nalaman ang mga bank accounts na yan? Violation ng bank secrecy law yan.
Complain nya naman eh, bakit yung mga evidence nyo eh nakukuha nyo lang through subpoena? Abay manong inadmissible yan kung di nakuha yan through summons dahil bank records po yan.
And he's implying that evidence via mode of discovery is not allowed. Ika ng mga dean ng college of Law ng UP at UST eh di nila maintindihan ang complain ni enrile.
Bugok ang mga prosecutor and so is the court.
dapat may katabi si enrile na assistant or someone that will remind him... magaling si enrile pero hindi maitatanggi na may edad na talaga sya... marahil eh dala na din ng pagod yan.. gusto na din umuwi ng mga yan but duty calls them
Yep, seems like manong johnny's age is finally catching up with him.. But I would still prefer him as chair for the impeachment court than any other senator. :D
But mind you, Enrile is a b4d4ass lawyer during his heydays.. It was reported that he never lost a single case during his lawyering days
I agree, I prefer that he will preside over the hearing. Sana meron mag remind sa kanya parati, wag yung ugok na pro tempore. Imagine a pro tempore in the person of jingoy sitting there. Disastrous yung ginawa nya kahapon, instead na tumawag sya ng point of order ginatungan pa nya sablay ni enrile.
Kakahiya yun, di naka tiis si Escudero tumawag ng point of order.
Last edited by CoDer; February 14th, 2012 at 11:23 AM.
ok na yan si enrile, napagod lang siguro talaga kahapon.. kesa naman si Villar kung sia nagkataon na Senate President tapos meron impeachment...
can't comment about the proceeding yesterday dahil hinde ko napanood nag update lang ako sa twitter yesterday.
May guerra kanina sa plenary versus the birthday boy at si malaking mata. Nagsigawan yung dalawa. Nagapologize naman si big eyes kay birthday boy after...
nagkagulangan siguro sa partihan... kaya nagkagulo sila... kulang daw ang binigay sa kanila ng palasyo...
High-blood na naman si Brenda sa "strange" documents daw ng prosecution :D