Is it bad to turn the engine on and off frequently

[danegoesonline]

Im a Grab Driver and after I drop the passenger off I am turning off the engine to save fuel consumption, after 5-10 minutes I will start it again. Is this ok? Am I shortening any parts of my car? Please help, I will appreciate it very much.

[maxpedition]

Im a Grab Driver and after I drop the passenger off I am turning off the engine to save fuel consumption, after 5-10 minutes I will start it again. Is this ok? Am I shortening any parts of my car? Please help, I will appreciate it very much.

No problem and you also help save our environment [emoji106]

Sent from my SM-G955F using Tapatalk

[Vodka]

ok lang yan. some newer cars even have auto start stop systems. automatically kills engine when idling

starter is an electric motor and is usually very reliable

what's bad are repeated short trips. like starting cold then driving 1km. then rest 1hr. starting cold again. rinse repeat

[danegoesonline]

Pero ano po yung na wear na parts pag nag iistart ng engine? Spark plug?

[dr. d]

Im a Grab Driver and after I drop the passenger off I am turning off the engine to save fuel consumption, after 5-10 minutes I will start it again. Is this ok? Am I shortening any parts of my car? Please help, I will appreciate it very much.

i used to that with my diesel, during long stoplights.
hayun... battery died on the 13th month, 1 month after warranty expired.

[papi smith]

Doc, in my experience with Motolite Gold , patama talaga ang life nya sa warranty na 21 months, minsan lang ako naka tyempo ng more than 2 years and malas na na trade in ko pa for a new one due to mis diagnosis of faulty alarm module.

[dhenz76]

Pero ano po yung na wear na parts pag nag iistart ng engine? Spark plug?

IMO sir battery madali masira sa ganyan senaryo lalo na maiksi lang takbo kung sakali:-)

[sean-archer]

Im a Grab Driver and after I drop the passenger off I am turning off the engine to save fuel consumption, after 5-10 minutes I will start it again. Is this ok? Am I shortening any parts of my car? Please help, I will appreciate it very much.

Starter and battery.

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk

[yebo]

Pero ano po yung na wear na parts pag nag iistart ng engine? Spark plug?

1. Battery
2. Starter motor carbon brush, solenoid contacts and starter pinion gear. Yung carbon brush madali lang palitan. Most starter solenoids are now sealed type so palit yan buo. Also the pinion pag nabungi or worn out palit na agad at baka kasi madamay ang flywheel gear.

[danegoesonline]

i used to that with my diesel, during long stoplights.
hayun... battery died on the 13th month, 1 month after warranty expired.

Paps alam mo ba pagkabasa na pagkabasa ko ng reply mo ayaw na magstart ng tsikot ko, mag pajumpstart pako sa motolite.

[ninjababez]

Pero ano po yung na wear na parts pag nag iistart ng engine? Spark plug?

kung short trips, battery siguro ang pwede maapektuhan. easily remedied by buying a smart charger

[DiliKoAmericano]

A sensible question to ask. It all comes down to the health of the entire electeical system. Grab driver, your car must be newish right? System should be fine to turn on and off.
The situations where it would be a problem...
An aged battery, would take a significant boost charge to recover after every start compared to a newer battery. So if you constantly did this stopping and starting on an older tired batery, 2 bad things would start occurring.
1. The current going through the starter motor would start increasing and starter motor life would be shortened due to the resulting heat, and
2. The current needed by the alternator to replenish the significant discharge that the older battery took when supplying said current to the starter, would start increasing, shortening the life of the alternator.

So put simply, stopping the engine is really economical, only if your batterys health is at least 70%. If the health is lower than that (as measured on a decent industrial workshop battery tester) then you may actually be expediting the death of multiple electrical components beyond the value of the fuel saved.

One more factor, is fuel type. Diesel engines are significantly more efficient at idle than gasoline. So the battery health threshold for where this economical cutoff would be for a gasoline vehicle is slightly lower than an a diesel. i.e, a gasoline engine might be better off switched off rather than idling at 70% battery health, but a diesel uses ao little fuel at idle it might better left on, unless battery health was so good it did no harm to the battery health.
I hope that makes sense.

[SoleusBB]

As far as I know it doesn't cost much to restart an already warm engine, compared to continually running on idle.
I don't know with these new computer controlled engines but they should be more efficient pa nga eh.

In an effort to reduce pollution, sa NYC nga, idling for over a certain number of minutes is a violation (pero never naman na enforce yun sa kanila, AFAIK)

As to yung mga jeeps & buses natin na pilosopo pa yung driver ("konti lang matitipid na krudo pag pinatay ang makina!"), I think yung main concern nila is baka hindi na nila mai-start ulit yung mga poorly maintained engines nila so they just keep it running.

[papi smith]

As to yung mga jeeps & buses natin na pilosopo pa yung driver ("konti lang matitipid na krudo pag pinatay ang makina!"), I think yung main concern nila is baka hindi na nila mai-start ulit yung mga poorly maintained engines nila so they just keep it running.

I think their using weak batteries na and would rather keep their engines idling than buy a new one... I bet, push start ang mga ito sa umaga

Really annoying noise and pollution if they happen in front of your house

[jaypee10]

Paps alam mo ba pagkabasa na pagkabasa ko ng reply mo ayaw na magstart ng tsikot ko, mag pajumpstart pako sa motolite.

encounter ko ito sa motollite wala pang 1 year nasira kaagad buti under warranty pa kaya palit ng bago...kaya mas maganda kung mga 5 mins lang naman hintayin mabuti pang wag patayin nalang makina.kasi battery at starter ang maaring masira.

[Walter]

As long as your trips are about 5 kms or 15 minutes, your vehicle will be fine ... Prolonged idling also has more drawbacks compared to frequent starting and stopping of engine ... As long as they are not very short trips (1-3 km or 5 minutes) ...

[danegoesonline]

As long as your trips are about 5 kms or 15 minutes, your vehicle will be fine ... Prolonged idling also has more drawbacks compared to frequent starting and stopping of engine ... As long as they are not very short trips (1-3 km or 5 minutes) ...

Naku e puro short trips ako e.

[Archerfish]

A sensible question to ask. It all comes down to the health of the entire electeical system. Grab driver, your car must be newish right? System should be fine to turn on and off.
The situations where it would be a problem...
An aged battery, would take a significant boost charge to recover after every start compared to a newer battery. So if you constantly did this stopping and starting on an older tired batery, 2 bad things would start occurring.
1. The current going through the starter motor would start increasing and starter motor life would be shortened due to the resulting heat, and
2. The current needed by the alternator to replenish the significant discharge that the older battery took when supplying said current to the starter, would start increasing, shortening the life of the alternator.

So put simply, stopping the engine is really economical, only if your batterys health is at least 70%. If the health is lower than that (as measured on a decent industrial workshop battery tester) then you may actually be expediting the death of multiple electrical components beyond the value of the fuel saved.

One more factor, is fuel type. Diesel engines are significantly more efficient at idle than gasoline. So the battery health threshold for where this economical cutoff would be for a gasoline vehicle is slightly lower than an a diesel. i.e, a gasoline engine might be better off switched off rather than idling at 70% battery health, but a diesel uses ao little fuel at idle it might better left on, unless battery health was so good it did no harm to the battery health.
I hope that makes sense.

If I may ask, aside from using hygrometer, is it possible to know the health of your battery by using a multimeter?

[yebo]

If I may ask, aside from using hygrometer, is it possible to know the health of your battery by using a multimeter?

Search "battery tester" in olx or lazada.

[dhisky]

My car is 3 years and half already. 15k odo pa lang pero almost everyday ginagamit and short distances lang, like mall and church lang (1-3km) or sa kabilang street lang. On and off din engine.

Bumigay agad starter. Not sure if it has something to do with turning on/off the engine or bad batch lang since may mga nakita akong same car model and gen na same issue as mine sira rin agad starter.

Pero at 15k odo sira agad starter?