Manual transmission for me.(while physically able) Drove an AT when I was in the US for more than a month and did not enjoy the experience.
2 months ago I was deciding on whether I will get a Toyota RAV4, Toyota Fortuner or Honda CR-V. When I learned that the CR-V manual tranny is 6 speed, it was one major reason for getting it(CR-V). Never owned a 6 speed manual tranny before. Love driving it!
Of course 5 to 10 years from now, my preference might change. (If traffic in my area worsens and my legs give up)