View Poll Results: Should Michael Phelps compete again in 2012?
- Voters
- 10. You may not vote on this poll
-
Yes
8 80.00% -
No
2 20.00%
Results 21 to 28 of 28
-
-
August 19th, 2008 12:45 PM #22
Yes he should, he should compete for 7 more consecutive olympics, and each time win 8 golds to make it 8, 8 and by the 8th olympics, he might already be in his 80's ...and wow 8, 8, 8 lucky numbers again
-
BANNED BANNED BANNED
- Join Date
- Jul 2003
- Posts
- 2,267
August 19th, 2008 01:43 PM #23afaik, mark spitz 7 of 7. 7 gold medals. 7 world records. and he said that if they have a 50m freestyle back then, he would have won it also.
Well you said Phelps electrified the US population to swimming. However, you cannot equate that to the criteria "degree of impact to the sport" when talking about greatness. why? because the impact is only in the US. and afaik, the world is not only the US.
and relay events swimming are not really "team" sport. they don't pass on their suits and goggles, dont they? plus, as what some internet articles said, phelps owe one of his teammates (lezak if i am not mistaken) one of his gold medals. that teammate of his really was the one who rallied againts the french that classic relay event.
anyway, i don't mean to downgrade any of phelps' accomplishments. i'm just trying to put it in a proper context. in fact i think, he is a great swimmer, probably the greatest. but not the greatest olympian or athlete for that matter.
and to answer the main question: he should rest and think hard before committing to London 2012.
-
August 19th, 2008 11:22 PM #24
quit while your're on top, yes he could made history now, and he will strive for more but more will surface, and next time he might not be so lucky...
stay on top!
-
August 19th, 2008 11:22 PM #25
quit while your're on top, yes he could made history now, and he will strive for more but more will surface, and next time he might not be so lucky...
stay on top!
-
August 20th, 2008 05:10 AM #26
It's almost guaranteed someone will break Mike Phelps' records someday. In the meantime, if he can hack it, then he should keep competing until he feels he's done.
Should I just quit playing soccer because of my age? Most guys my age are either getting fat with beer bellies or have become couch potatoes and let themselves go.
Me, I can still mix it up with their kids and show em a thing or two.
Most people think sports is all about winning and setting the bar above others. But in reality, it's all about improving one's self.Last edited by Jun aka Pekto; August 20th, 2008 at 05:29 AM.
-
August 20th, 2008 06:57 AM #27
-
August 20th, 2008 08:07 AM #28
see, the problem with any discussion about "greatest" is that there isnt a consistent definition of the word. is it most wins? is it margin of victory? is it dominance for a year, or sustained dominance? or is it impact on the sport?
two athletes that fit all those definitions and perhaps a few more are Tiger Woods and Michael Jordan. maybe Michael Schumacher if you consider auto racing a sport. problem is, none of them really made their marks on the Olympics...besides a certain "Dream Team" appearance.
so, back to the Olympics. i don't think you can ever crown a single "greatest" without a lot of argument. but i think he does deserve to be mentioned at least in the top 5. i won't argue Carl Lewis (he comes closest to all the definitions above). impact? can anyone top Jesse Owens? could Phelps be in the top 3 with these two? arguably yes. and if he competes and does well in London, then yes without a doubt.
Be careful with channels like "China Observer" on YouTube. There is a clear bias in their posts and...
Xiaomi E-Car