Question about Hyundai's AT

**Jet PAC** · August 8th, 2013 11:37 PM

I'm a newbie AT owner. Been driving a MT since 1998. In an AT, if I press on the brakes with the vehicle still in motion, I normally return from D to N in preparation to stop. Now the problem is, I sometimes overshift to R but with my feet still pressing on the brakes. Will this damage my transmission? In comparison to a MT where you hear a craking sound if you mistakenly shift gear, at least I haven't heard of any. Correct me if I am wrong. In an AT, if I press on the brakes, this is also equivalent to pressing on the clutch in the case of an MT, wherein the effect is the gears are temporarily disengaged?

**gearhead000** · August 8th, 2013 11:59 PM

Short answer: You don't need to shift to N from D when approaching or preparing for a stop. Just brake to slow the car down, then brake to a complete stop. Depending on whether you're in a stop, you can stay in D if it will be a short one... or shift to N or P if it's going to be long.

**renzo_d10** · August 9th, 2013 12:11 AM

^ IMO, unless you're really PARKED, it is normally safer to just put the gear on N then apply handbrake on traffic. When I use AT cars, I don't put the gear on P during traffic cause of the risk that it passes through R to and fro D.

**KIANTOT** · August 9th, 2013 08:55 PM

Originally Posted by renzo_d10

^ IMO, unless you're really PARKED, it is normally safer to just put the gear on N then apply handbrake on traffic. When I use AT cars, I don't put the gear on P during traffic cause of the risk that it passes through R to and fro D.

Agree on this, may mga driver na kapag nag stop sa traffic they put on P, kaya kung ikaw ang sumusunod magugulat ka dahil iilaw yung backing light, one time may nasundan ako na ganyan ang ginagawa kada stop, lipat agad ako ng lane mahirap na baka magkamali si mokong.

**dr. d** · August 9th, 2013 12:19 AM

Originally Posted by Jet PAC

I'm a newbie AT owner. Been driving a MT since 1998. In an AT, if I press on the brakes with the vehicle still in motion, I normally return from D to N in preparation to stop. Now the problem is, I sometimes overshift to R but with my feet still pressing on the brakes. Will this damage my transmission? In comparison to a MT where you hear a craking sound if you mistakenly shift gear, at least I haven't heard of any. Correct me if I am wrong. In an AT, if I press on the brakes, this is also equivalent to pressing on the clutch in the case of an MT, wherein the effect is the gears are temporarily disengaged?

like what the guy above says, just brake without disengaging your trans, until you come to a stop. then put the trans on N or P.
shifting from D to R at speed may unduly stress your AT. in the looong run, it may cause early AT retirement.
some models won't let you shift from D to R while at speed, as a precaution.
pressing on the brakes in AT is just like pressing on the brakes in MT: the gears are still engaged, only the AT allows slippage. no, it ain't the equivalent of a clutch.
and experts agree that N is the proper position when the car is not moving for some time. remaining in D with your brakes on to keep the car from moving, puts stress on your engine and trans, and brakes.

**boytsiks** · August 9th, 2013 12:28 AM

I would normally put the car to stop before shifting D to N. Havent tried shifting an AT car in motion though.

* TS - Not sure if this also applies to Hyundai AT's, mine still has this shifter button. I dont normally press it when shifting from D to N to avoid overshooting to R or P. I just push it back and forth when shift D to N and vice versa.

**Jet PAC** · August 9th, 2013 03:50 AM

Thank you all for the Inputs. Actually, I just did it 3x accidentaly shifting from D to R but at decelerating speed (around 20-10kph) and while pressing on the brakes. And yes when I'm stopped by a traffic light I shift to N and apply the hand brakes because I noticed staying on D at prolonged stop still puts stress on the engine.

**ishtangli** · August 9th, 2013 11:37 AM

Originally Posted by Jet PAC

Thank you all for the Inputs. Actually, I just did it 3x accidentaly shifting from D to R but at decelerating speed (around 20-10kph) and while pressing on the brakes. And yes when I'm stopped by a traffic light I shift to N and apply the hand brakes because I noticed staying on D at prolonged stop still puts stress on the engine.

I'm by no means an expert but I dont think keeping it in D while stopped puts stress, if any, on the engine, unless you have bad idling. Remember, the engine will continue to rotate/combust even when you are stopped. It just doesnt connect to the drive shaft (in the case of an AT, the torque converter). Also remember, AT is designed for this.

**Walter** · August 9th, 2013 02:38 PM

Originally Posted by ishtangli

I'm by no means an expert but I dont think keeping it in D while stopped puts stress, if any, on the engine, unless you have bad idling. Remember, the engine will continue to rotate/combust even when you are stopped. It just doesnt connect to the drive shaft (in the case of an AT, the torque converter). Also remember, AT is designed for this.

This method will consume more fuel.

**Walter** · August 9th, 2013 02:43 PM

Originally Posted by Jet PAC

Thank you all for the Inputs. Actually, I just did it 3x accidentaly shifting from D to R but at decelerating speed (around 20-10kph) and while pressing on the brakes. And yes when I'm stopped by a traffic light I shift to N and apply the hand brakes because I noticed staying on D at prolonged stop still puts stress on the engine.

Shift the transmission without pressing the knob / switch. You can shift from R-D-N-D-2-1-2-N without pressing the switch. You need to press the switch to go from D to R to P.