Strada 2.5 gl or innova 2.5 j ??

[franceyangtze]

patulong naman po... pinagpipilian ko kasi ang dalawang ito.. i know magkaiba sila . please share your thoughts at baka sakaling makatulong sa akin mag decide..

gagamitin lang for family use.. gagamitin ni misis pag wala ako.

i liked the pick up kasi madaming paglilibangang mods pang pueding gawin, masarap dalhin sa malubak naming daan.
i liked the innova kasi more passenger ang nasa loob..

about sa FC , san matipid sa dalawa? city drive, short trips(5km from A to B) light traffic...

planning to kept the car for a long time....

TIA

[Walter]

Toyota Innova, the pickup is nice but for family use the Innova is better. The novelty of having a pickup will soon wear out, you can't load items on the pickup bed when it's raining, even when it's not, they might not be safe there. Innova will be able to pass by bumpy roads also and it's more fuel efficient in the city. The only thing with the Innova is that the 2014 look is not as good looking as before the update.

[joey_ed27]

Based on your usage- Innova. Its carlike drive fits city driving well. Seating capacity is a big difference.


Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[josejose44]

+1 on the Innova

[dct]

Mukhang wants lang yung strada. Needs ang innova. So innova ang mas ok

[franceyangtze]

thanks sa mga input ... malaking tulong ito sa akin...

sabi sa kabilang thread , matipid pag diesel compare sa gas, but medyo malaki ang maintainance ng diesel compare naman sa gas. tanong ko lang, mga magkano nagagastos pag nasiraan ka ng ganitong parts sa diesel ?? para maging handa sa haharapin....



1. Injectors - may fail due to dirty diesel
2. EGR - may fail due to dirty diesel
3. Turbo
4. SCV problem

[crosswind]

thanks sa mga input ... malaking tulong ito sa akin...

sabi sa kabilang thread , matipid pag diesel compare sa gas, but medyo malaki ang maintainance ng diesel compare naman sa gas. tanong ko lang, mga magkano nagagastos pag nasiraan ka ng ganitong parts sa diesel ?? para maging handa sa haharapin....



1. Injectors - may fail due to dirty diesel
2. EGR - may fail due to dirty diesel
3. Turbo
4. SCV problem

Never pa ako nasiraan ng ganyan sa innova
saan-saan ko pinapagas yan kahit sa province
basta regular PMS di ka maapektuhan niyan
kung sakaling mag fail injectors mo it will cost as much as 100k or more

[D3nb3r]

To TS, your comparing apples and oranges. Innova would be good if passenger and better ride comfort ang concern mo.
For cargo carrying capacity and ground clearance against flood water, there is no contest, the pick-up will out perform the innova. For example lang. sometimes nag kakarga ako nang mga maruming bagay, like compost, woods and even live animals like goats and chickens. Now if you get the innova, I don't think you would like how the goat and chickens will smell inside the innova. Since I don't think you would be loading same cargos like mine, the Innova will be the best fit for your lifestyle.
FC: wag ka masyado maniwala sa mga nag sasabing car A is more fuel efficient than car B (if both are 2.5 diesel). FC boils down to individual driving style. Kahit alin sa dalawa kukunin mo if mabigat naman paa mo and you change gear at high rpm(manual tranny), then your FC will always suffer.
Maintenance: All reputable car makers regardless of brands have tested their units and spent millions of dollars on R&D. So it's up to you which one to buy. Just bear in mind that no car is invincible and there is always a lemon. Even if you have the cheapest brand of car/pick-up but religiuosly folow PMS, that cheapo will always outlast any expensive car/pick-up that does not get a routine PMS.

[dr. d]

I wouldn't be surprised if the naysayers of a particular brand, don't even own one... Not to mean their opinions don't count.. But is it just possible that.... those who do own one, are probably so satisfied with the car, they don't mind at all these possible problems in the future..

And I don't mind comparing apples to oranges.. After all, we are interested in the driving characteristics and not the name..

[GTi]

Between the two, I'd go for the Strada, if only for the power amenities. :D And then again, it's a proven car, the vehicle of choice of San Miguel corporation for their corporate fleet in fact. It does have it's disadvantages though, and having a Strada GLS Sport V in the family, I am quite familiar with them. Do make sure that the missus is comfortable with the Strada's length. Definitely not very easy to park, especially in parallel parking. Steering is heavier than most. Being a pickup, you will have to invest in either a canopy (our Carryboy canopy cost 67k) or a lockable bed cover to keep your things from the elements and out of prying hands. There's no reaching them from in the cabin either, unless you opt for the 4x4 variant with the opening rear window wherein you can reach the stuff placed at the back of the bed.:D The bed itself is also on the small side.

The Innova is definitely the more practical and versatile between the two. You get seating for 8. With all the seats folded up you get a cargo area that can rival a pickup bed. Engine performance is good enough for most. If I were to get one though, I'd stay away from the J and go for a 1-2 year old used E or G variant instead.

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2

[franceyangtze]

points taken mga bosing, now im weighing the use/purpose of the vehicle na kung sakaling magkaron ako nito ano posibleng laging gamit nito. more on passenger or more on loading cargoes... gusto ko din kasing sulitin ang gamit dito para di sayang... first car ko to na medyo may kamahalan.... kaya pinagiispan ng maigi.. nasanay na kasi sa mumurahing motor at multicabs upgrade namn daw ng kaunti para pan regalo sa sarili at di tamarin mag hanap buhay...

[playplugg]

points taken mga bosing, now im weighing the use/purpose of the vehicle na kung sakaling magkaron ako nito ano posibleng laging gamit nito. more on passenger or more on loading cargoes... gusto ko din kasing sulitin ang gamit dito para di sayang... first car ko to na medyo may kamahalan.... kaya pinagiispan ng maigi.. nasanay na kasi sa mumurahing motor at multicabs upgrade namn daw ng kaunti para pan regalo sa sarili at di tamarin mag hanap buhay...

Sir franceyangtze,

kung upgrade naman ng sasakyan, kung ano po yung gusto nyo talaga, go for it na! 5kms ang (back and fort) saka wag nang-tipirin (self reward ika nga...hehehe )

low mileage user ang gamit ng sasakyan nyo sir...hehehe

[franceyangtze]

Sir franceyangtze,

kung upgrade naman ng sasakyan, kung ano po yung gusto nyo talaga, go for it na! 5kms ang (back and fort) saka wag nang-tipirin (self reward ika nga...hehehe )

low mileage user ang gamit ng sasakyan nyo sir...hehehe

haha.. marami akong gusto at mahal kaya di ko kaya,... dito muna ako sa kakailanganin ko na makakamura.. hehe.. mahirap ding makuha natin ang gusto natin sa sasakyan pero nag susuffer ang iba nating pangangailangan...

[franceyangtze]

yong difference ng innova j sa E model parang power amenities lang diba?? window at yong dagdag sa stereo setups..

di ba napapagawa din sa labas yong power windows?/.. magkano inaabot nito??.

[playplugg]

yong difference ng innova j sa E model parang power amenities lang diba?? window at yong dagdag sa stereo setups..

di ba napapagawa din sa labas yong power windows?/.. magkano inaabot nito??.

Sir franceyangtze,

J,& E variant, standard na merong ABS saka airbag...accessories lang nagkakatalo.

[dr. d]

So why don't I warm up to pick-ups? well, they're longer than the innova, and I really don't need that cargo space at the back.

[babybackrivs]

yong difference ng innova j sa E model parang power amenities lang diba?? window at yong dagdag sa stereo setups..

di ba napapagawa din sa labas yong power windows?/.. magkano inaabot nito??.

Sa innova J steel rim lang, sa E mags talaga

[soyti75]

i thought of this comparison once before when i was considering budget. but i came to the point na Strada was the far better choice than the Innova, for me. I have the GLS V matic strada, and it has served me well for the past 1 and a half years. Little things like when i bought a new ref, a rocking chair, had my german shepherd and labrador in a cage transported to the vet, had a road trip and around 8 people at the cargo bed doing steep inclines on rough roads, and i can go up to 160kms/hr on NLEX if i want to. These little things were easily done with the Strada, which i doubt would be the case with the innova. But wait, it is true you would have to spend more for added security, like spare tire lock, cargo cover ( i had a storage box installed instead as you would need it when the cabin is full with people, and only 5 can fit in there). It is true you would not need the bed always, but it is a great feature when needed. Plus of course the higher ground clearance of the strada (but you MUST change the tires to bigger ones)

[GTi]

yong difference ng innova j sa E model parang power amenities lang diba?? window at yong dagdag sa stereo setups..

di ba napapagawa din sa labas yong power windows?/.. magkano inaabot nito??.

AFAIK between J and E ang dagdag ay power windows and locks, alloy wheels, ABS and rear wiper. I personally find these things to be worth the money.

Mura lang ang aftermarket power windows and locks. You'll see lots of them in Olx. Less than 5k lang, though I'm uncertain of the quality.

Not considering slightly used 2nd hand bro?

Sent from my GT-I9100 using Tapatalk 2

[Stewmaker]

Innova....kung pangfamily.got 2008 glx strada and 2014 innova e both are manual transmmision.pareho ang fuel consumption ko sa highway 15/km liter.tsinek ko maintenance receipt ko.mas mahal maintenance ng strada.
Strada full synthetic 615/ liter oil filter 1052 ( mitsubishi valle verde )innova full synthetic 570.53/liter oil filter 380 ( toyota bicutan ).both are casa maintain.