Violation posted by police station on top of minor accident?

**kevindd992002** · December 7th, 2016 01:44 AM

So I got into a minor accident with a Hyundai H100 tonight at McKinley road. My car is a Mistubishi Montero. The damage is a simple scratch (no dents). Long story short, we had to acquire a police report in the Market Market police station as a requirement for the H100's insurance. Mine doesn't have any insurance anymore. It was a hassle but we needed to go through it. The thing that I can't get over with is the fact that the two policemen there said they had to confiscate both our license as we have an automatic violation (as mandated by Taguig City's ordinance bullcrap) of P2000 w/ seminar. So we were both amazed because halatang "namemera" lang. I pleaded and haggled until they agreed at P500. This is really bothersome because I've a friend who got in an accident in BGC earlier this year, went to the same police station, and was never tagged with any sort of violation.

Why did this happen and what can I do with this? Can I file a formal complaint in LTO to investigate this? Or what's the correct process so that I can get my P500 back?

**_Cathy_** · December 7th, 2016 02:03 AM

That's probably the Taguig Police that you dealt with?

Based on my experience (and other friends), BGC traffic police NEVER accepts bribes.

**ninjababez** · December 7th, 2016 02:15 AM

Originally Posted by kevindd992002

So I got into a minor accident with a Hyundai H100 tonight at McKinley road. My car is a Mistubishi Montero. The damage is a simple scratch (no dents). Long story short, we had to acquire a police report in the Market Market police station as a requirement for the H100's insurance. Mine doesn't have any insurance anymore. It was a hassle but we needed to go through it. The thing that I can't get over with is the fact that the two policemen there said they had to confiscate both our license as we have an automatic violation (as mandated by Taguig City's ordinance bullcrap) of P2000 w/ seminar. So we were both amazed because halatang "namemera" lang. I pleaded and haggled until they agreed at P500. This is really bothersome because I've a friend who got in an accident in BGC earlier this year, went to the same police station, and was never tagged with any sort of violation.

Why did this happen and what can I do with this? Can I file a formal complaint in LTO to investigate this? Or what's the correct process so that I can get my P500 back?

What To Do During Vehicular Accidents

mmda nga lang bro di LGU
pero may nabasa nga ako ganyan dati, technically kasi obstruction yun nangyari dahil sa accident eh.

**kevindd992002** · December 7th, 2016 03:08 AM

Originally Posted by _Cathy_

That's probably the Taguig Police that you dealt with?

Based on my experience (and other friends), BGC traffic police NEVER accepts bribes.

Well, if the police in the Market Market station is also the "Taguig police" then yes.

Originally Posted by ninjababez

What To Do During Vehicular Accidents

mmda nga lang bro di LGU
pero may nabasa nga ako ganyan dati, technically kasi obstruction yun nangyari dahil sa accident eh.

What do you mean "mmda lang hindi LGU" bro?

Pero bakit dun sa friend ko hindi naman nagkaroon ng violation kahit same police station?

**kevindd992002** · December 7th, 2016 03:32 AM

Hindi ko ma-edit yung post ko sa taas, ano ba tong tsikot na website na to, bakit parang sira sira yung GUI? Post ko na lang yung edited version ng post ko sa taas:

Originally Posted by _Cathy_

That's probably the Taguig Police that you dealt with?

Based on my experience (and other friends), BGC traffic police NEVER accepts bribes.

Well, if the police in the Market Market station is also the "Taguig police" then yes.

Originally Posted by ninjababez

What To Do During Vehicular Accidents

mmda nga lang bro di LGU
pero may nabasa nga ako ganyan dati, technically kasi obstruction yun nangyari dahil sa accident eh.

Hindi mo naman sinadya yun e. Na-aksidente ka na nga tapos bibigyan ka pa ng violation? Pano kung may namatay, may violation pa din? It doesn't make sense!

Saka bakit dun sa friend ko hindi naman nagkaroon ng violation kahit same police station?

**ninjababez** · December 7th, 2016 03:35 AM

Originally Posted by kevindd992002

Well, if the police in the Market Market station is also the "Taguig police" then yes.

What do you mean "mmda lang hindi LGU" bro?

Pero bakit dun sa friend ko hindi naman nagkaroon ng violation kahit same police station?

ibig ko sabihin bro, iba iba depende sa lugar at kung sino humuli sayo
e.g. mmda violation, ticket pero you get to keep your license; pasig blue boys tubusin mo license mo sa munisipyo

**ninjababez** · December 7th, 2016 03:39 AM

Originally Posted by kevindd992002

Hindi ko ma-edit yung post ko sa taas, ano ba tong tsikot na website na to, bakit parang sira sira yung GUI? Post ko na lang yung edited version ng post ko sa taas:

Well, if the police in the Market Market station is also the "Taguig police" then yes.

Hindi mo naman sinadya yun e. Na-aksidente ka na nga tapos bibigyan ka pa ng violation? Pano kung may namatay, may violation pa din? It doesn't make sense!

Saka bakit dun sa friend ko hindi naman nagkaroon ng violation kahit same police station?

re: editing, depende sa browser at pag over prescribed period yun post, di mo talaga ma-edit
re: violation/traffic accident = obstruction, wag ka sakin magreklamo di ako gumawa ng batas na yan

pero sa tingin ko lang, nagkabanggaan tayo; naka istorbo tayo sa ibang motorista

**Stigg ma** · December 7th, 2016 08:14 AM

may resibo ba yan binayad mo P500?

**kevindd992002** · December 7th, 2016 08:41 AM

Natry ko na sa lahat ng major browsers (Edge, FireFox, and Chrome) and sira talaga GUI ng forum. Ung mga ibang clickable buttons all over the place sila and distorted.

Oo nga, obstruction of traffic nga pero dahil yun sa aksidente hindi dahil naging reckless driving mo. Hindi ako nagrereklamo sayo bro, I just want to understand.

Isipin mo na lang ganito. Yung mismong traffic enforcers nga hindi ako binigyan ng ticket e. Pero yug police station na hindi naman talaga nakita yung pangyayari bibigyan ako ng ticket? Ni wala ngang nagescort samin papunta sa police station e. So yung police report ginawa lang talaga based sa salaysay ng both parties. Kung hindi lang naman dahil sa insurance nung isang car, hindi naman kami aabot pa sa police station to get a police report e.

Wala, walang resibo yung 500 so nagmukhang under the table na nga yun. Pero ang question dito is bakit may violation in the first place?

**kevindd992002** · December 7th, 2016 08:48 AM

Siguro yun ang isang information na hindi clear sa post ko. Ang nagbibigay ng ticket samin ay yung mga sa police sa police station na, not the traffic enforcers that were in the scene.

The traffic enforcers even mentioned that if we decide to get a police report we will be given violation tickets. Di lang kami naniwala dahil nangyari na samin dati to and wala namang nangyaring violation. Like I said, meron akong friend na three times ng nagkaroon ng aksident na minor na parang ganyan, all instances nagobstruct ng traffic (most often than not naman sa gitna ng kalsada ang mga ganitong minor accidents e) and walang violation na pinatong sa kanya kapag kumuha ng police report.

This is why I decided to powst in the forums. I want to know if you've already experienced this first hand.