Are rufino-prieto big time tax evaders?

[kagalingan]

Parang "kadamay" lang pala ito inquirer. Ang pinagkaiba lang nagbababayad ng kuryente at tubig. hahahahah!!!!

Inquirer owners’ unpaid rentals on govt’s ‘Mile Long’ prime property: P2B
By RIGOBERTO D. TIGLAO on April 21, 2017

Including Dunkin’ Donuts P1.5B, that’s P3B
RENT on the state-owned prime Makati property called the Creekside/Mile Long complex which the Rufino/Prieto family, the main owners of the Philippine Daily Inquirer (PDI), owe government—but to this day have not paid—would total a mammoth P1.8 billion, computed up to May this year, according to a government suit filed in 2009.

(The PDI’s main, controlling owners are the Rufino/Prieto family with 75 percent. The next biggest shareholder, with 25 percent, is a firm set up using the pension fund of PLDT, which Indonesian magnate Anthoni Salim controls.)

If government’s claims are valid, and its figures accurate, the Rufino/Prietos’ liabilities through their firm Sunvar Realty and Development Corp. would be this P1.8 billion, plus the P1.5 billion alleged tax evasion by another firm they own, Dunkin’ Donuts. That would total nearly P3 billion, putting them in the league of Chinese-Filipino tycoons notorious for being tax evaders.

No wonder President Duterte himself angrily said in a recent speech that he will investigate the case, which was reported to him as having been a “sweetheart deal” when it was leased by a state firm to the Rufino/Prietos’ firm Sunvar Realty Development Corp.

The P1.8 billion figure is based on what then President Arroyo’s Solicitor General Agnes Devanadera in 2009 through the metropolitan trial court asked Sunvar to pay, using figures determined by the government’s Privatization Management Office that had taken over the property. This consists of ₱630 million for the “illegal and unauthorized” use and occupation of the property from 2003 to March 31, 2009, and ₱10.4 million per month from April 2008 until the property was surrendered to government.


Inquirer owners’ unpaid rentals on govt’s ‘Mile Long’ prime property: P2B
TWO PRESIDENTS, TWO TREATMENTS: Could the Mile Long case (background) explain it?

The property was originally leased to the Prieto firm in 1980 and 1983, allegedly at a scandalously low rental by the Technology Resource Center Foundation, controlled at the time by Imelda Marcos. The lease expired in 2002, although the Prietos continued to control the property as if nothing happened, and refused to vacate it.

If you think that P1.8 billion figure is unbelievably huge, consider the following. The Rufino/Prieto firm continued to control the 29,000-square meter prime commercial property in Makati (between Amorsolo and Chino Roces Avenue, valued now at about P6 billion) and collected rentals from the over 400 stores there for 14 years, after its lease expired in 2002. That P1.8 billion amount translates to a measly rent of P360 per square meter per month government is asking Sunvar to pay—a give-away price in a prime area where rents are at least P50,000 per sq. m. per month.

Country of oligarchs
Can you imagine anywhere else in the world where a rich family manages to control a government-owned urban prime property, and sublease it to businesses, even if its lease had ended 14 years ago? What a country ruled by oligarchs! Or perhaps as I pointed out in my previous column: such is the power of media in the Philippines.

For reasons unexplained or perhaps expected, the case dragged on that government asked the Supreme Court for help, which issued a decision in June 2012 that practically said the Rufino/Prieto firm should pay ASAP what it owned the state, since it didn’t even challenge the “factual issues” of the case:

“The Court notes that respondent Sunvar has continued to occupy the subject property since the expiration of its sublease on 31 December 2002. The factual issue of whether respondent has paid rentals to petitioners from the expiration of the sublease to the present was never raised or sufficiently argued before this Court. Nevertheless, it has not escaped the Court’s attention that almost a decade has passed without any resolution of this controversy regarding respondent’s possession of the subject property…

The Court emphasizes the duty of the lower court to speedily resolve this matter once and for all, especially since this case involves a prime property of the government located in the country’s business district and the various opportunities for petitioners to gain public revenues from the property.”

Only in the Philippines: Even with the order of the Supreme Court, it still look three years for the lower court to issue a decision. Metropolitan Trial Court Judge Barbara Aleli Briones in July 2015 ordered the Rufino/Prieto firm to pay up, although she reduced the amount to P555 million, 30 percent of the P1.8 billion government asked.

Sunvar would certainly go bankrupt if it is asked to pay just that P0.6 billion, as its assets amount to only P400 million.

In a country where there is a rule of law, and perhaps where even the most powerful media firm is treated just like any other firm, the Rufino/Prieto firm would have paid up immediately, and the story would have ended.

Next court levels
But not in the Philippines. The Rufino/Prieto firm filed several cases in the next levels of the court system, all of which did not question the facts of the case but merely raised such obscure technicalities as the metropolitan court’s jurisdiction and the need to consolidate all cases—which the company itself filed.

The orders last year up to March 2017 of the judges involved—Makati Regional Trial Court Branch 141 Maryann Corpus-Manalac and MRTC Branch 59 Judge Winlove Dumayas—have in effect allowed the Rufino/Prietos, to maintain the status quo—to control the property, collect rents from businesses there, and ignore government’s decade-long effort to collect P550 million to P1.8 billion from this billionaire clan.

Isn’t it uncanny that the efforts to reclaim the Creekside/Mile Long property started during the watch of President Macapagal-Arroyo, whom the PDI demonized, were practically suspended during the entire term of President Aquino, whom the paper unabashedly idolized and supported? And that the first real court decision on the matter was in July 2015, when Aquino just had a year to go?

Guess who really gets to appoint judges to higher level, even up to the Supreme Court? Such is the sad state of our institutions.

It would be so tragic if after fourteen long years, government because of sheer incompetence fails to recover a prime property and to get its rent from one of the richest clans in the country have managed not to pay.

What would the hundreds of thousands of urban poor squatters in the metropolis say when riot police try to eject them? “Why us poor, not the rich squatting on prime government land?”

Inquirer owners’ unpaid rentals on govt’s ‘Mile Long’ prime property: P2B - The Manila Times Online

[StockEngine]

this is good 😁

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tsikot Forums mobile app

[kagalingan]

Walangdyo inquirer ito.....

May terror group na nga eh naglabas pa ng PEKENG PHOTO.

Mahilig talaga MANDUGAS

Kaya presdu wag kalimutan ang tax and penalties sa dunkin donut at bawiin yung lease sa makati property.... Resbak resbak.....

[kagalingan]

Hahhaahah..... kadamay na kadamay style nito inquirer ah...

Solgen to Prieto firm: Vacate Mile Long, pay P1.65-B tax
By Perseus Echeminada (The Philippine Star) | Updated July 29, 2017 - 12:00am



Photo taken yesterday shows the Mile Long complex on Amorsolo street in Makati City. The government says potential revenue from the property, developed by Sunvar Realty Development Corp., will be used for the rehabilitation of conflict-stricken Marawi City and government hospitals.ERNIE PEÑAREDONDO


MANILA, Philippines - Sunvar Realty Development Corp. should settle some P1.656 billion it owes the government and vacate the 2.9-hectare Mile Long property in Makati City, Solicitor General Jose Calida said yesterday.

“You cannot do this to the Filipino people. When you speak against the government of President Duterte, it’s like you’re immaculately clean. You have used your newspaper, the Philippine Daily Inquirer, to shield your shenanigans,” Calida said in a press conference in his office across the property.

Former PDI owners, the Prieto and Rufino families, control Sunvar.

Calida likened Sunvar to the Kadamay urban poor group whose members took over housing units meant for soldiers and police in Bulacan recently.

“In truth, you guys are like the Kadamay squatters. You have been depriving the government of money that could have been used to fund projects for the poor,” he said.

Sunvar’s legal counsel Alma Mallonga called Calida’s claim a “gross mischaracterization” of the situation.

“We’d like everyone to understand that Sunvar had a perfectly legitimate expectation of believing that its contractual commitment would be honored. That is all that is happening today,” she told ANC’s Market Edge.

The solicitor general said Sunvar has refused to leave the property despite the expiration of its lease agreement with the government on Dec. 31, 2002. Sunvar began occupying the property in February 1982.

“Despite notices, Sunvar continued to remain in possession and collect millions of rentals from its tenants,” he pointed out.

Calida said that since 2003 or for the last 14 years and seven months, Sunvar has been squatting, illegally using and occupying the Mile Long property and despite notices, continued to remain in possession and collect millions of rentals from tenants.

In 2009, the government filed a complaint for Unlawful Detainer against Sunvar Realty before the Metropolitan Trial Court for its illegal and unauthorized use and occupation of the Mile Long property.

According to Calida, an ejectment case is summary in nature as it intends to provide an expeditious means of protecting right to possession.

“From the get-go Sunvar never questioned the factual issues of the case. They just delayed everything. They filed baseless motions reaching up to the Supreme Court. That’s why it took almost six years before it was decided by the Metropolitan Trial Court,” he said.

“Instead of abiding by the decision by vacating the property and paying the rent, Sunvar filed a prohibited pleading after another to stop the government from implementing the decision,” Calida said.

He said Judge Winlove Dumayas of RTC Makati allowed Sunvar to maintain control of the property and collect rent from businesses.

“How so? Dumayas issued a TRO in favor of Sunvar. Sunvar had its appeal consolidated with the injunction case raffled to Dumayas. Notorious Dumayas then granted Sunvar’s appeal and dismissed the injunction,” he said.

“It should be noted that it took Dumayas 10 months to dismiss the injunction petition, which in the first place he knew he had no jurisdiction over,” Calida maintained.

“Worse, after the Court of Appeals found Dumayas having no jurisdiction, he held the records hostage. It was only when I personally went to his court in RTC Makati a few months ago that the records were elevated to the Court of Appeals,” Calida pointed out.

The Office of the Solicitor General, he said, has a pending Very Urgent Ex Parte Motion for Execution before the Court of Appeals.

Solgen to Prieto firm: Vacate Mile Long, pay P1.65-B tax | Headlines, News, The Philippine Star | philstar.com

[kagalingan]

[chronicle]

Sobrang tagal na pala tong issue sa sunvar. Article is from last year

Prietos get to keep Mile Long, etc., for now | BusinessMirror

[Monseratto]

Get out of Mile Long property, court tells tenants | Money | GMA News Online

[Monseratto]

Mga collateral damage... some japanese restos are also going bye-bye tomorrow... last night na nila.


A Farewell to the Japanese Restaurants of Mile Long in Makati

The many Japanese restaurants in Mile Long, adjacent to Little Tokyo (which is said to be closing in just 18 months), are considered an extension of Little Tokyo itself, and a number of them have been there for several decades.

A visit to Mile Long at 5PM today saw offices in an emotional flurry to vacate the premises within the allocated time. Conversations with employees of tenant companies telling us that they have until tomorrow to fully vacate the buildings.

Which means tonight may be your last chance to pick up some of your loved dishes—at least for the time being. While the fate of these local icons hangs in the air, we will be sending them off with several rounds of grilled meat, raw fish, and sake. See you there?

[crazy_boy]

Saan na kaya lilipat yung secret japanese wagyu restaurant.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[_Qwerty_]

pati Pharoah?