Sienna Recall

**Macky** · October 2nd, 2003 05:14 AM

I've been in the market for a family car and was doing a research on the Sienna. We're more or less choosing between the '04 MDX and '04 Odyssey when the plush interior of the Sienna caught my fancy. Anyway, TMC is recalling almost 35,000 Siennas due to the fuel tanks being prone to damage and could cause a fire according to the NHTSA. During one of the IIHS's severe frontal-offset crash tests, a part of Sienna'sfuel tank was damaged. IMO, the earlier the better in finding faults para ma-correct agad. I'm still seriously considering the Sienna but the options could get expenssive. In fact, it could reach the RX330 price range with the feautures I prefer :whoa:

**Macky** · October 2nd, 2003 05:43 AM

BTW, the Sienna won a recent comparo in MT or CD (not sure) against the Quest and Odyssey.

**Karding** · October 2nd, 2003 07:39 AM

may dilemma ka pa din pala on which Family Van to get. Pero Quest pa din ako...

**papa tots** · October 3rd, 2003 01:20 AM

if i was residing in the US and i need a van, my choices would be the honda odyssey or nissan quest.

but the 2004 quest will be having IMHO the best engine in the world right now, so this would be my choice.

**kuroy** · October 4th, 2003 02:36 AM

agree ako diyan...

i had driven oddysey and sienna so far, pero ang quest ang bang for the buck. lagyo ng agwat sa pricing i was about to buy an oddysey, pero noong natest drive ko sa dealer ang quest..hindi ko na binitiwan

super quiet ng engine and ang sarap ng suspension pag nagdaan ka sa hump or lubak parang crown victoria ang pakiramdam.

will be buying a 04 quest soon, hands down alang second thought. ganda pa ng interior ng bagong quest.

i have seen new sienna on the roads already parang hindi striking ang dating ng exterior...

of course asa taste iyan ng gagamit pero quest ala kang talo sa price and performance

**Macky** · October 7th, 2003 03:20 AM

Here's CR's recommendations (model and price as tested):

1. Toyota Sienna LE - $28,188
2. Honda Odyssey EX - $30,360
3. Mazda MPV ES - $29,345
4. Nissan Quest 3.5 SL - $27,780
5. Dodge Grand Caravan eX - $29,390
6. Chevrolet Venture LS - $29,745
7. Ford Windstar SE Sport - $30,815
8. Kia Sedona EX - $24,920

CR's Good all-around choices:
Sienna
Odyssey
Quest
The Sienna has better fuel economy, a quieter cabin, more available features (which quickly becomes costly), and offers all-wheel drive. The Odyssey has better handling. All three has spacious interior and a comfortable ride.

If compactness and nimble handling are more important:
MPV
The MPV is smaller than the Sienna, Odyssey, or Quest, which makes it feel almost as quick, roomy, or comfortable.

For used model, the 2001 Honda Odyssey is the best choice.