Don't pay too much attention on OB's posts. We all know he can get very opinionated on things. Once in a while though, his posts do carry some weight.

Going back to the topic, the XV is clear winner if you talk about overall capability and performance. The Ecosport is a better comparison to the Juke. If budget is a key concern, the Juke or Ecosport are worth considering though at its price, a compact car like the Sylphy/Altis/Focus/Civic is a better buy. If you do have the budget for an XV, a Forester is a more practical option as it is bigger.