I'm on the same boat with Syuryuken's decision. I'd consider the Ranger over these two MPVs. If I do want to get myself an MPV, the Innova is the most practical choice.
Definitely agree. For a people carrier, Innova or wag nalang.
Then again, the cheapest automatic Innova is 1.2M (1.3M for the diesel). That's ~200k more than the Rush and Xpander.