HR-V or CX-5

[perfectstranger]

actually i was planning to get accent hb or jazz but flood might be a problem so i'm going for a crossover instead.

based on my budget, either HR-V E or CX-5 maxx would fit the bill. since i needed to save more, i'll probably buy around late 2016 or early 2017. kindly share your thoughts on which is a better buy between the two.

thanks!

[StockEngine]

2.0L skyactiv is worth the extra penny. And the yojin service package is good imo even though some say its abit too much. Ive seen the cx5 go thru 350mm water hehehe.

So many hr-v and vezels in kl malaysia. Its super popupar there. It looks small from the outside.

[Walter]

Mazda CX-5 would have the higher ground clearance than the Honda HR-V.

[MR_BIG18]

Mazda CX-5 would have the higher ground clearance than the Honda HR-V.

The hrv, is is not underpowered for its size?

[dct]

actually i was planning to get accent hb or jazz but flood might be a problem so i'm going for a crossover instead.

based on my budget, either HR-V E or CX-5 maxx would fit the bill. since i needed to save more, i'll probably buy around late 2016 or early 2017. kindly share your thoughts on which is a better buy between the two.

thanks!

Bigger discounts for end of the year than start of the year

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

[Walter]

The hrv, is is not underpowered for its size?

Power is adequate unless you're a speed freak ...

[Egan101]

No contest, go for the CX5.

[sientobente]

Does the CX-5 Maxx use the same deep cycle batteries as the Mazda 3 and higher end CX-5? If it does, malaking portion ng expense yan when the time comes to replace the battery. How's the feedback on the PMS cost after Yojin3? Kasi sa Honda mas mura ang PMS nila after 3-years, pwede na magtake advantage na ng mga promo nila. Just some thoughts to consider.

[Egan101]

If really going for a Honda, it would be much better to get a CRV instead. Please take note that both Honda crossovers have lower ground clearance compared to the competition.

[Walter]

Does the CX-5 Maxx use the same deep cycle batteries as the Mazda 3 and higher end CX-5?

Same engine, same features i-Stop and all. Also 6 airbags, major difference would be fabric instead of leather seats, non-LED headlights, ordinary HU system instead of Mazda connect system.

[Walter]

Consider the Subaru XV or Forester also. Better ground clearance, AWD, 6 airbags.

[jhnkvn]

If really going for a Honda, it would be much better to get a CRV instead. Please take note that both Honda crossovers have lower ground clearance compared to the competition.

Let's face it, malulunod muna ang mga sedan before any HRV-CRV does I would rather recommend people to exercise their brains into judging to ford the water rather than simply going "yolo" in a crossover.

[Egan101]

Let's face it, malulunod muna ang mga sedan before any HRV-CRV does I would rather recommend people to exercise their brains into judging to ford the water rather than simply going "yolo" in a crossover.

Very good point, bro! Kapag malakas talaga yung ulan, be safe and stay home.

[niky]

Do note: Neither car is rated for flood fording. The CX-5's air intake sits over the grille, however, while the HR-V's intake goes through the grille (better than the CR-V... our intake is in the bumper)... so the CX-5 should be a bit safer... but neither car is guaranteed to be able to survive a thorough soaking.

If you really want a flood-proof car, buy one with a rated wading depth. This ensures that electronics and transmission/oil coolers are sealed from water intrusion below this depth.

-

When in doubt... simply DON'T.

[GTi]

I've seen a CX5 fording a flooded East Ave. near Heart Center. All traffic was stopped at either side of the flooded area with only the buses crossing. Water level was lapping on his headlights if I remember correctly. It was only after he crossed safely that I decided to cross (with a Revo diesel) 😁. All the lights on my instrument panel were blinking erratically even then. My hats off to that brave/foolish guy. Haha~

I once drove our Tribute 2.3 through a flooded Sto. Domingo St. Flood wasn't that high, with quite a few taxis in front of me. Even then I could feel the water hitting the floorpan. Even though I've seen that it's air intake is somewhere behind the left headlight, it scared the hell out of me. 😄

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[Walter]

When in doubt... simply DON'T.

This rule also applies when overtaking ...

[niky]

I've seen a CX5 fording a flooded East Ave. near Heart Center. All traffic was stopped at either side of the flooded area with only the buses crossing. Water level was lapping on his headlights if I remember correctly. It was only after he crossed safely that I decided to cross (with a Revo diesel) 😁. All the lights on my instrument panel were blinking erratically even then. My hats off to that brave/foolish guy. Haha~

I once drove our Tribute 2.3 through a flooded Sto. Domingo St. Flood wasn't that high, with quite a few taxis in front of me. Even then I could feel the water hitting the floorpan. Even though I've seen that it's air intake is somewhere behind the left headlight, it scared the hell out of me. 😄

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

I recall how one concerned customer approached one of the motoring journalism oldies with concerns of how their Escape's engine block had holes in it after they drove it through a flood.

Defective daw.

Idiots.

[Walter]

^^^ Tulfo?

[niky]

^^^ Tulfo?

Been a long time. Newspaper column, if I recall. Might be Butch's column, but not sure.

[Fyzee Alim]

Also in the same situation, how does the Mazda cx-5 compare in terms of long-term reliability/meintanance?