Nissan Grand Livina or Toyota Innova ?? [MERGED]

[tidus1203]

For a budget of less than a million. Which would you rather get, an Innova E VVT-i A/T (oh yeah it has to be automatic) or the Nissan Grand Livina Elegance? Tinatanong lang ako ng isa kong acquaitance, sabi ko sa kanya parang mas gusto ko pa yung Livina since high end compared to the E na medyo bare bones model. Kayo ano sa tingin nyo? Oh yeah kung may iba pa kayong suggestions na less than a million pak sabi na din. Wag nga lang sedan kasi he likes the car to have a little bit of versatility just in case.

[tidus1203]

Wala bang opinions and comments?

[vinrem]

Between the 2, id go for the grand livina, fc is good and maganda ang interior compare to the innova, i especially like the size kasi not too big and not too small, kaya tamang-tama lang, also mas bago and design compare to the innova w/c has been here for quite some time na.

[welscua]

Between the 2, id go for the grand livina, fc is good and maganda ang interior compare to the innova, i especially like the size kasi not too big and not too small, kaya tamang-tama lang, also mas bago and design compare to the innova w/c has been here for quite some time na.

I agree

[coiter]

kung 'versatility' ba it needs to be a 7-seater? kung yes the only options i can think of are the fuzion and other antiquated AUVs (adventure and crosswind). otherwise, the tucson would be a good all-arounder, sans the 2 extra seats, for less than 1M.

phased out na pala yung mga gas carens.

but between the 2 (innova and GL), sa high end GL na ko. that's unless i live in a flood prone area with lots of potholes or that i always carry heavy loads. kung ganun, sa innova na.

[Gerbo]

The E variant is not really barebones kasi meron ng power amenities. Personally I'm not into gasoline MPVs.

Anyway, the two choices are too close to call for me. A test drive would then be imperative for the buyer.

Grand Livina has better interior. The Innova is bigger. What's the buyer's priority?

[tidus1203]

Actually 4 lang naman sasakay. The third row is just to add cargo (you know during out of towns and going to the cemetery etc...) or the very rare instance may iba pang sasakay....

[ianmitsulancer]

hmmm... talagang close call ito ah...

thanks to sir Gerbo for asking the preferences!

considering that tidus1203's acquaintance will be a relatively light user, yes, the Grand Livinia is the next best thing based on my initial impressions. as mentioned, the FC is good and it will be much better since 4 lang ang sasakay. if it was the other way around with more people to ride in and prone to floods & rough roads, the Innova would be better.

also, there is an active roster of Grand Livinia users in the tsikot forums. i encourage that he can meet up with them anytime soon before the purchase to get a heads up of what to expect with the GL. i just hope that spare parts for the GL will be readily available.

on a personal note, it resembles my Space Wagon!

[tidus1203]

Correction lang po, hindi po ako bibili may kakilala lang ako...

[gelahascue]

So tsikoteers, i just read a comparo on livina and innova in youtube. well, according to this man (KPKonliner) i think he chose the livina over the innova. so tsikoteers, let us discuss your opinions about this comparo.

from KPKonliner:
Well , its not fair to compare a large MPV with a hatch-wagon but both almost has the same price.Its up to u wheter u want Grand Livina or Innova.

Innova might be roomier BUT not economical.As u see in the video , driving Innova is like driving a ship ( It's huge , it's tall ,the suspension is too soft ,feels heavy ).With a heavy weight also affect the fuel consumption,making it a less economical car.

On the other hand , Grand Livina's shorter profile increase aerodynamic , stability,and downforce.Well , its not as roomy as Innova but at least the driver is happy too.Plus Grand Livina has higher quality interior ( the fabric/leather seats are high quality and the other plastics are great )and its more comfortable than Innova.What da ? Innova is way roomier and I still think Grand Livina's more comfortable !? yes,thanks to Grand Livina's brilliant suspension settings ( a collaboration of Nissan and Renault ).It seems that there's a little bit European touch for the suspension.It's stable when cornering but also comfortable at bad roads.Yet,Grand Livina has less body roll.Remember,not just comfortable for passengers but also for driver.

Again with the fuel consumption,Grand Livina is smaller,shorter,more aerodynamic,lighter,bla bla bla...and one thing that might impress u , because Grand Livina is a Nissan Livina with larger cargo and has third row seats , that means it has almost similar fuel consumption as the hatchback version.This is impressive because , believe me or not , Nissan Livina's ( not grand Livina ) fuel consumption can beat Honda Jazz and Toyota Yaris !!! BUT it depends on how you drive , remembering that the engine response is less responsive than Honda Jazz and Yaris , you need to be patient , and when you do , it'll save more fuel than Yaris do.Innova is too heavy,huge,big and has high ground clearance.The other reasonable factor is the off road chassis ( which is also used for off road SUVs).



SO,which one is better ? I would say Grand Livina.Reason ? I know Innova is roomier but we're living in 2009 ! and modern cars should be practical and economical.Grand Livina might be smaller but it saves a lot of fuel , handles well , higher quality ,more comfortable , and it can accommodate 7 people in a compact size.Brilliant car ! simply brilliant ! still thinking to buy Innova ? think twice !

[Gerbo]

The Livina (promoted by Nissan as a sedan with 2 additional seats) drives like an estate which is traditionally not a seller in the Philippines.

[p_borj]

Grand Livina ako. Siyempre Nissan ito so panalo sa aircon hehe. Sa looks mas gusto ko rin ito pati interior.

Grand Livina - Drives like a sedan you'll forget its an MPV.

Innova - Drives like a MPV plus you gas a lot.

[emms1121]

Hindi comparable bro. MPV vs AUV. Livina is comparable sa space wagon ng mitsu only a little bigger. Yung pagiging magaan at malaking makina (1.8) ang nagcontribute sa good fc ng Grand Livina.

[jrebong0]

You can always compare two cars, and at the end of your comparison you chose the one that best fits you according to your needs..

[gelahascue]

yup correct ka diyan sir emms1121, for me naman value for money na sana ang Livina kung height displacement eh mataas ng konti and sana auto climate control. hehehe. well sakin lang naman yun.

[dr. d]

it would depend on the road conditions i normally encounter. if it's well-paved roads all the way, with no flooding, i'd probably get the nissan. but if the road conditions are bad and/or there's frequent flooding, it's the innova.

[gelahascue]

sorry there was already a thread about this, thanks sa pagmerged. hehe. yup it all depends sa use ng car and purpose mo. well for me, yeah looks are fresh for the grand livina and the FC is good but in the end if i really have the budget id go for the innova V. swak na sa needs ko and sa Pinas talaga hindi maiiwasan ang mga palubakan na daan at pataasan ng baha. so, better safe than sorry, well this is just for my personal opinion. but both cars are good and value for money..

[MAXBUWAYA]

If its Value. Innova.

I think Livina is too expensive.

[renzo_d10]

Innova for me.

Aircon ata ng livina nasa harap lang eh. Pano nq yung nasa 3rd row seats.

[eggman]

Mas ok ang Grand Livina...