C class, 3 series or A3 based on maintenance costs?

[imperialv]

Hi guys,

If all done in casa, no breakdown just basic PMS. Which of three has the lowest maintenance costs.

[imperialv]

Assuming 2013 model and 5 years ownership.

[ronw123w124]

Can't speak for the others, for my wife's '12 318i (E90) it cost us P4,477.93 for its first oil change service or oil service in BMW speak.

[imperialv]

Please correct me on this, audi daw ang pinaka mahal sa 3 in terms of PMS..

Can't speak for the others, for my wife's '12 318i (E90) it cost us P4,477.93 for its first oil change service or oil service in BMW speak.

[viper888]

Can't speak for the others, for my wife's '12 318i (E90) it cost us P4,477.93 for its first oil change service or oil service in BMW speak.

My dads 318i is exactly the same
His service first came out at about P6200
It had 11800kms (it was 50kms to service according to the screen) when it was serviced and it was at Autozentrum BMW

*ronw123w124 Where was your wife's car serviced and how many kms did it have?

Edit:
Audi (post warranty) maintenance will be cheaper when VW gets here
Audi A3=VW Golf
Audi A4=VW Passat
Audi A8=VW Phaeton
Audi Q7=VW Touareg

[ronw123w124]

My dads 318i is exactly the same
His service first came out at about P6200
It had 11800kms (it was 50kms to service according to the screen) when it was serviced and it was at Autozentrum BMW

*ronw123w124 Where was your wife's car serviced and how many kms did it have?

Edit:



Audi (post warranty) maintenance will be cheaper when VW gets here
Audi A3=VW Golf
Audi A4=VW Passat
Audi A8=VW Phaeton
Audi Q7=VW Touareg

I had it serviced at Autohaus Libis, it had around 1,200 km when I brought it in for service last week

[viper888]

I had it serviced at Autohaus Libis, it had around 1,200 km when I brought it in for service last week

That explains why it was more expensive. Did you bring it in when the screen in the dash said so?

I think a BMW would cost the least to service. The only problem are the runflats for a 3-series. Tires cost 80k a set in the dealership. Its at least 150k a set for an X5 M Sport.
Audi has a 5 year warranty. BMW only has a year 2 year warranty

How about waiting for the new Lexus IS
Will be cheaper with a bigger engine thanks to JPEPA
NO runflats

[ronw123w124]

That explains why it was more expensive. Did you bring it in when the screen in the dash said so?

I think a BMW would cost the least to service. The only problem are the runflats for a 3-series. Tires cost 80k a set in the dealership. Its at least 150k a set for an X5 M Sport.
Audi has a 5 year warranty. BMW only has a year 2 year warranty


How about waiting for the new Lexus IS
Will be cheaper with a bigger engine thanks to JPEPA
NO runflats

I brought it in when the screen on the dash said "Service Due" or something like that. On the runflats, I ditched them early on because of the very uncomfortable ride comfort, I replaced them with ordinary tires and just put some tire sealant in them just in case I get a flat tire.

[the_wildthing]

If it was me I wouldn't care too much about maintenance costs among the three. I'd choose the one that would I'd be most happy to drive. I'd go for the a3 Quattro if it was the hatch. Plus upgrades from APR. Hehe

[speed_kills]

T
How about waiting for the new Lexus IS
Will be cheaper with a bigger engine thanks to JPEPA
NO runflats

Ah yes, Lexus is launching the new IS very soon....2.5M for standard version and 3M for F-sport.

Some features the IS350 will have over 3-series/C-class/A4 include 306hp V6 engine, 8-speed AT, DVD, Bluetooth,built-in navi (first time in the Philippines?), all LED exterior lighting, sunroof, etc.

[Egan101]

Below is a comparison test by Car and Driver for BMW 335i M-Sport vs Cadillac ATS 3.6 vs Lexus IS350F Sport. Car and Driver rated the IS350F Sport better over the other two.

Habemus Papem! 2013 BMW 335i M Sport vs. 2013 Cadillac ATS 3.6, 2014 Lexus IS350 F Sport ? Comparison Test ? Car and Driver

[imperialv]

I already saw the LEXUS is350 in lexus manila.. The formal lauching will be the 11th which I will also attend.. We have the 2013 ES350, and more or less have an idea how much is the maintenance costs.

I would appreciate more if a comparo on how much does PGA, CATS and ACC charges to PMS..

BUILT IN NAVi, baka first on its class.. Tsaka OEM talaga at hindi gaya ng ibang kotse na CHINA MADE HU... Saw the HU of the IS350 F-SPORTS, really a beauty..

Ah yes, Lexus is launching the new IS very soon....2.5M for standard version and 3M for F-sport.

Some features the IS350 will have over 3-series/C-class/A4 include 306hp V6 engine, 8-speed AT, DVD, Bluetooth,built-in navi (first time in the Philippines?), all LED exterior lighting, sunroof, etc.

[speed_kills]

I would appreciate more if a comparo on how much does PGA, CATS and ACC charges to PMS..

I don't remember how much CATS charged for PMS but it wasn't a big deal for me and I suppose it is more or less similar with the other premium brands.

But what I do remember is after the 2 year warranty expired, a previous MB I got started having problems like aircon and suspension with 100k in each repair bill. I finally had enough and sold it at a very cheap price.

I really like MB, BMW, and Audi cars as they have really cool and premium designs. But they don't seem to last here so I would think twice before buying again.

[speed_kills]

Below is a comparison test by Car and Driver for BMW 335i M-Sport vs Cadillac ATS 3.6 vs Lexus IS350F Sport. Car and Driver rated the IS350F Sport better over the other two.

Habemus Papem! 2013 BMW 335i M Sport vs. 2013 Cadillac ATS 3.6, 2014 Lexus IS350 F Sport ? Comparison Test ?*Car and Driver

Interesting review considering a 328 already costs 4.3M while the 320d is already 3.5M. I can just imagine how much a 335 will be in case it gets sold here.

The upcoming IS350 that's much faster (306hp), handles well (RWD), and costs a lot less than a base 3-series will be a strong value proposition in the premium compact sedan class.

[ghosthunter]

Hi guys,

If all done in casa, no breakdown just basic PMS. Which of three has the lowest maintenance costs.

Tie between Honda Civic and Toyota Corolla.