
Originally Posted by
jut703
In a nutshell, the Jetta has a better (diesel) engine plus German build quality and exclusivity which the Civic 1.8E doesn't. The Civic on the other hand has top-class Japanese tech and gadetry, a smoother transmission, and the assurance of easier long-term ownership in terms of maintenance and parts availability.
Engine-wise, the 2.0 diesel of the Jetta is more economical. And unlike the Civic's 1.8 that needs to be revved hard to feel the power, the Jetta will shove you in your seat with its low-end torque. My drive with the older Jetta can be described as effortless - it doesn't seem to feel stressed even with a full load.
0-100 of the Jetta is under 9 seconds, the Civic does it in 10-something. Not only does the Jetta accelerate faster, it also feels faster. This is in no small part due to the DSG dual-clutch transmission of the Jetta with instantaneous shifts, whereas the Civic has a relatively lifeless CVT that just drones at the redline when pushed hard. Both cars top out at around 210 kph, however the Civic actually accelerates quicker to 200 kph since the Jetta has long 5th and 6th gears while the Civic's CVT hovers at the redline all throughout.
When it comes to day-to-day driving though, the Civic's CVT easily trumps the DSG in terms of smoothness. All dual-clutch transmissions suck in bumper to bumper traffic.
The judgment on the interior will depend on your taste. The Jetta is typical German - reserved (some might same boring) and simple, but elegantly done. The Civic on the other hand is as high-tech as it gets. Both are well made, although the 1.8E doesn't feel as premium as its RS brother due to the lack of leather anywhere. In comparison, all variants of the Jetta are already leather-clad.
The case for the exterior is also the same. If you like understated elegance and simplicity, the Jetta will impress you. On the other hand, if you like the attention-grabbing physique of the Civic, then the Jetta would look boring. Personally, I appreciate both aporoaches and wouldn't mind either.
In terms of kit, it depends on what variant you're comparing. The base Comfortline has small 16" rims just like the Civic. Both cars would definitely benefit aesthetically from a set of 18-inchers, though the 17s on the Highline are already good enough.
Both cars have got the basics covered - push-button ignition, Bluetooth connectivity, and touch screen head units. You'll need to step up to the Highline to get climate control, which the Civic 1.8E already offers. The Highline also one-ups the Civic with its 8-speaker Fender speakers, power driver's seat, and rain sensing wipers.
The Civic comes stock with LED headlights, which is only offered on the Businessline and Businessline+ Jettas. To parry that, even the Comfortline offers a sunroof, though I'd prefer the brighter headlights on most days. Annoyingly, the Comfortline doesn't even come with fog lamps.
At the end of the day, the Jetta charms me because it's different and rather rare. Not to say that the Civic is a bad car - objectively, both are excellent choices and it really depends on your preference.
Sent from my SM-N9208 using Tapatalk