No right turn on red light sign?

[kris_13]

Kung walang sign it means pwede.

Minsan naman right lane must turn right, dame nadadale dito nyan sa pasig lalo na yung mga dayo lang dito. Di sila pwede mag contest kasi ang laki nung sign.

[RC-V]

para maiba...

actually sa makati, based on traffic ordinance, you can turn right on a red light provided walang sign that indicates otherwise.

2010,2011 2012 can't remember the exact year, I was flagged down at Makati, bawal daw mag-right turn on red signal. Sabi ko sa QC kasi pwede, sabi ng traffic enforcer, iba daw sa Makati. Tapos a year later or so, nagkalat na signage na no right turn on red.

[sirkosero]

2010,2011 2012 can't remember the exact year, I was flagged down at Makati, bawal daw mag-right turn on red signal. Sabi ko sa QC kasi pwede, sabi ng traffic enforcer, iba daw sa Makati. Tapos a year later or so, nagkalat na signage na no right turn on red.

sir, pinerahan lang kayo nun. the ordinance took effect in 2003 at wala pang nirepel na provision.

[testament11]

Siguro ganito nalang

As what I had said, pag wala yung sign, pwede kang kumanan kahit red ang traffic light, but with caution/care. Now, provided nasa right lane ka at wala kang intention lumiko at may sasakyan sa likod mo na kakanan, bubusinahan ka niyan at pag nagkataong may TE around the area, pwede kang mahuli for obstruction. Kung i-cocontest mo sa TE na naka-red ang traffic light, sasabihin niyan sa iyo na, oo naka-red nga, pero wala naman nakalagay na bawal lumiko, kaya in the end, pwede ka niyang ticketan.

Now, kung may sign na "no right turn on red signal", yan talaga ang bawal. Pag lumiko ka, at may TE, huli ka. Now, paano naman kung may sasakyan sa likod mo tapos gustong kumanan? You have the right na hindi kumanan at hayaan mo siyang businahan ka ng businahan. Pag di tumigil kakabusina, babaan mo tapos pakita mo yun signage sa driver nang matahimik.

[e2romo]

Now, provided nasa right lane ka at wala kang intention lumiko at may sasakyan sa likod mo na kakanan, bubusinahan ka niyan at pag nagkataong may TE around the area, pwede kang mahuli for obstruction. Kung i-cocontest mo sa TE na naka-red ang traffic light, sasabihin niyan sa iyo na, oo naka-red nga, pero wala naman nakalagay na bawal lumiko, kaya in the end, pwede ka niyang ticketan.

I would argue na where's the sign that says "vehicle on this lane must turn right." Similar to the sign in BGC on some of the roads. Wala naman sa batas na kailangan kumanan ang nasa right most lane on intersections.

[taurusX]

well-explained

[j_avonni]

para maiba...

actually sa makati, based on traffic ordinance, you can turn right on a red light provided walang sign that indicates otherwise.

Hinuli ako sa corner of Makati Ave. (from Buendia) turning right to Jupiter. There are no signs whether "no right turn on red signal" nor "right turn with caution." The TE said it's the former and I argued it's the latter. The TE let me go.

[mda]

It seems that in the Philippines, each intersection has its own rule.

Bottom line for me -- if hindi ko kabisado yung 'rule' for that intersection, I stop and wait for the green light before proceeding (with matching right turn signal).

Kapag binusinahan na ako nang matagal ng mga nandoon sa likod ko, I can almost assume it is safe to turn right kahit naka red hehe.

[wezz_zzew]

Generally, If there is no sign, you can turn right anytime. Same with those intersections with TURN RIGHT ANYTIME WITH DUE CARE.
Pag may nakalagay na NO RIGHT TURN ON RED SIGNAL, di talaga pwede. But in every rule, there is always an exceptions.

Exceptions:
1. Ambulance/Fire Truck/Police car passing thru
2. VIP's with escorts passing thru
3. Government Service Vehicles
4. No TE on sight.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Generally, If there is no sign, you can turn right anytime. Same with those intersections with TURN RIGHT ANYTIME WITH DUE CARE.
Pag may nakalagay na NO RIGHT TURN ON RED SIGNAL, di talaga pwede. But in every rule, there is always an exceptions.

Exceptions:
1. Ambulance/Fire Truck/Police car passing thru
2. VIP's with escorts passing thru
3. Government Service Vehicles
4. No TE on sight.

[kimbon]

Generally, If there is no sign, you can turn right anytime. Same with those intersections with TURN RIGHT ANYTIME WITH DUE CARE.
Pag may nakalagay na NO RIGHT TURN ON RED SIGNAL, di talaga pwede. But in every rule, there is always an exceptions.

Exceptions:
1. Ambulance/Fire Truck/Police car passing thru
2. VIP's with escorts passing thru
3. Government Service Vehicles
4. No TE on sight.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Generally, If there is no sign, you can turn right anytime. Same with those intersections with TURN RIGHT ANYTIME WITH DUE CARE.
Pag may nakalagay na NO RIGHT TURN ON RED SIGNAL, di talaga pwede. But in every rule, there is always an exceptions.

Exceptions:
1. Ambulance/Fire Truck/Police car passing thru
2. VIP's with escorts passing thru
3. Government Service Vehicles
4. No TE on sight.

agree 1 & 2 but 3 & 4 totally disagree here. As far as I know no exceptions for gov't vehicles. same rights lang ito ng private/PUV etc... kapag NO RIGHT TURN ON RED SIGNAL pero nag proceed ang private vechiles ay may violation ito. kung ang rason ng motorist, eh ngpotpot nasa likod kong gov't vehicle at bakit ako lang ang hinuli mo? sagot ng TE di ko mahuhuli yan dahil nag iisa lang ako at saka ikaw ang unang nagviolate ng traffic sign...

item nos 4, always remember follow the traffic rules with or without TE on sight.

[e2romo]

Hinuli ako sa corner of Makati Ave. (from Buendia) turning right to Jupiter. There are no signs whether "no right turn on red signal" nor "right turn with caution." The TE said it's the former and I argued it's the latter. The TE let me go.

If maramdaman ng TE na maalam ka sa batas trapiko at tama argument mo lagi kang makakawala. It's just a matter of assertion. Malaking tulong rin ang dashcam, to serve as proof kung talagang pusakal na mangongotong yung nanghuhuli sa iyo.

[jodski]

Yan nga ang pangpagulo dyan... Bawat municipality at topak ng traffic enforcer may kanya kanyang diskarte.

[CVT]

If we'll base it on the sign, does it mean we can always turn right on red by default?

Yup,- but with caution. Yielding to oncoming traffic and pedestrians... That's the international law....

Dapat nga wala na ang mga signs na iyan,- pampagulo lang sila... But more importantly,- kulang sa disiplina kasi ang mga Pinoy drivers.- basta nasa unahan sila,- isasaksak ang kanilang sasakyan.... Hindi marunong ng "with caution" at "yield"....



"The measure of a man is what he does with power" LJIOHF!

26.3K _/_/_/_/_/:piano:_/_/_/_/_/

[Boy Torotot]

Ka-stress mag drive sa Pilipinas...hehehe.

[gwapster]

Ka-stress mag drive sa Pilipinas...hehehe.

Dapat lang alam natin ang tamang rules, tapos kapag sinisita ng enforcer pero alam nating nasa tama naman tayo, ipaliwanag sa kanyang alam natin yung rule at idispute ito nang maayos na paraan.

[jodski]

^ ayan o... Classic example ng topak ng enforcers pertaining to a simple rule.

Ano nga kinalabasan nito Sir JJ?

[rodetor]

If there is no sign of " No Right Turn On Red Signal" even the traffic light is lit red and you turned right with care on a National road. Wala ka dapat na maging traffic violation. And all I know that simple rule applies internationally. The "Red Light" in a traffic lights means "STOP" to all vehicles bound crossing through an intersection, and not to all vehicles turning right, unless, there is a "road sign" mostly posted at the right side of the road, telling you not to turn right on red signal.

Sent from my UP+ using Tapatalk

[cjaimejavier17]

Pwdeng mag right turn basta walang nakalagay na NoRightturn....
Pag hinuli kayo yun ang reason nyo dapat.

[WallyWest]

May significance ba ang placement ng traffic lights? Like for example may traffic light on a post at the corner of an intersection, does it mean no right turn on red?

I recall one time when a Makati enforcer flagged me down for turning right on a red signal. There was no "no right turn on red" sign. He said something about there being a stoplight overhead (which was apparently for those crossing) and another on the corner (for right turners, I suppose) so I shouldn't have made that turn.

[sean-archer]

May significance ba ang placement ng traffic lights? Like for example may traffic light on a post at the corner of an intersection, does it mean no right turn on red?

I recall one time when a Makati enforcer flagged me down for turning right on a red signal. There was no "no right turn on red" sign. He said something about there being a stoplight overhead (which was apparently for those crossing) and another on the corner (for right turners, I suppose) so I shouldn't have made that turn.

I'm curious about this traffic placement too. Can anybody confirm this? Pag nasa corner yung traffic light, included yung right turners sa stop?

Sent from my SM-G935F using Tapatalk