Should I buy the Gas or Diesel Innova?

[HoOn]

Hello! We're planning on buying an Innova and we still can't decide if we should go with the Gas or Diesel model. Can anyone give us some pros and cons of each? We've never really owned Diesel automobiles before that's why I'm a little hessitant about buying one now.

How is the reliability of each model in the long run? Is maintenance an issue? If gas or diesel money wasn't an issue what would you pick and why?

Thanks guys!

- John

[theveed]

Sakin lang, the price difference of both fuel types aren't that far apart, so I'd pick a gas variant, mas mabilis padin kasi and less maintenance sa fuel, oil and filters...

[HoOn]

wow! Thanks sa quick response.

[slamtaz]

hoon, i suggest you read the thread on "D4d engine problems" before you consider the diesel variant.

[niky]

Diesel
Pros:
-mas matipid sa fuel
-diesel is cheaper than gas
-strong torque makes driving in traffic easy

Cons:
-higher maintenance cost
-noise and vibration, diesel clatter
-less power than gas engines on the highway
-possible Toyota D4D problems regarding Philippine diesel quality, see relevant thread:
http://tsikot.yehey.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23197

Take note: these problems do not occur for everyone, but they should be a consideration.

Gas
Pros:
-lower initial purchase cost
-lower maintenance costs
-much quieter and smoother than diesel version
-good power for use on the highways

Cons:
-less fuel efficient, but consumption reported for the Innova is not bad. see this article:
http://www.c-magazine.com/c_article.asp?articleid=93

Also note that the cheapest Innova is the gasoline engine variant. And with no anti-lock brakes on the higher variants, there isn't much need to buy the more expensive versions.

EDIT: :lol: ambagal kong mag-type... naunahan tuloy!

[slamtaz]

Diesel
Pros:
-mas matipid sa fuel
-diesel is cheaper than gas
-strong torque makes driving in traffic easy

Cons:
-higher maintenance cost
-noise and vibration, diesel clatter
-less power than gas engines on the highway
-possible Toyota D4D problems regarding Philippine diesel quality, see relevant thread:
http://tsikot.yehey.com/forums/showthread.php?t=23197

Take note: these problems do not occur for everyone, but they should be a consideration.

Gas
Pros:
-lower initial purchase cost
-lower maintenance costs
-much quieter and smoother than diesel version
-good power for use on the highways

Cons:
-less fuel efficient, but consumption reported for the Innova is not bad. see this article:
http://www.c-magazine.com/c_article.asp?articleid=93

Also note that the cheapest Innova is only available with the gasoline engine. And with no anti-lock brakes on the higher variants, there isn't much need to buy the more expensive versions.

EDIT: :lol: ambagal kong mag-type... naunahan tuloy!

that's perfectly ok, it's not a matter of speed considering you got a more informative post.

[number001]

Also note that the cheapest Innova is only available with the gasoline engine. And with no anti-lock brakes on the higher variants, there isn't much need to buy the more expensive versions.

The Innova "J" variant which happens to be the entry level model, is available in Gas (vvti) or Diesel (D4-D) variants. Manual transmission only.

The Innova "E" variant, the mid-level variant, is available in diesel (D4-D) only. Manual transmission only.

The Innova "G" variant, the top-end variant, is also available in Gas (vvti) or Diesel (D4-D) variants. Automatic or manual transmission

[niky]

The Innova "J" variant which happens to be the entry level model, is available in Gas (vvti) or Diesel (D4-D) variants. Manual transmission only.

The Innova "E" variant, the mid-level variant, is available in diesel (D4-D) only. Manual transmission only.

The Innova "G" variant, the top-end variant, is also available in Gas (vvti) or Diesel (D4-D) variants. Automatic or manual transmission

Noted... I had to look it up muna... my mistake!

What I meant to say is that the cheapest variant is gas. Edited original post para walang ma-mislead.

Grabe nga pala, when I saw the price list, 50,000 pesos pala yung price difference.

Which means, even if oil changes for the diesel don't cost as much as I originally posted (sorry, afrasay, I'm just basing it on my casa experience with the 2.5D Crosswind), you'll still need to drive around 50,000km before you recoup the difference.

Nice choice, HoOn! I personally don't like paying that much for AUVs, but then, XUVi din yung Crosswind namin (highest variant), and I've got to admit, the extra toys are nice.

Now it's time to pimip that ride!

[knicks1204]

sabi sa amin nung isang sales associate sa toyota nung nagtingin kami kung pag city driving daw, mas okay ang GAS.. pero kung madalas out of town, mas okay daw ang DIESEL.. pero to hell with her, pinili pa rin namin yung gas.. lower maintenance cost sabi nga ni niky.. :D

[niky]

Ay, additional:

Every 5000 km, your diesel costs will be around 16,000 pesos (given urban traffic), at about 10 km/l.

Every 5000 km, your gasoline costs will be around 23,000 pesos (given urban traffic), at about 8 km/l.

A 5000km checkup for a 2.5 liter diesel vehicle will cost you around 4500 (dunno if the Innova is the same), while the 5000km checkup for a 2.0 gas vehicle costs around 2500.

Total cost per 5000 km is around 20,500 for diesel, and 25,500 for gas. You save about 5,000 pesos for every 5,000 km, or about 1 peso per kilometer with the diesel version. That's merely a rough estimate, mind you.

I don't know how much the price difference between gas and diesel variants is, but that also factors into your decision making.

Hey, for anybody who knows, is the Innova VVTi still on the 5,000 km sched or at 10,000km? If it is at 10k km, then the savings drop to about 3,750 pesos per 5,000 km.

Which means you'll have to drive at least 30-40k km a year to make back the cost difference between getting the gas and the diesel.

Pero with the possible pump problems you'll get with the diesel once you're past warranty, and the fact that it's a turbo (I think), will mean relatively more maintenance costs after three years than the gas variant, which will have steady maintenance costs over five to seven years.

[theveed]

Ay, additional:

Every 5000 km, your diesel costs will be around 16,000 pesos (given urban traffic), at about 10 km/l.

Every 5000 km, your gasoline costs will be around 23,000 pesos (given urban traffic), at about 8 km/l.

A 5000km checkup for a 2.5 liter diesel vehicle will cost you around 4500 (dunno if the Innova is the same), while the 5000km checkup for a 2.0 gas vehicle costs around 2500.

Total cost per 5000 km is around 20,500 for diesel, and 25,500 for gas. You save about 5,000 pesos for every 5,000 km, or about 1 peso per kilometer with the diesel version. That's merely a rough estimate, mind you.

I don't know how much the price difference between gas and diesel variants is, but that also factors into your decision making.

Hey, for anybody who knows, is the Innova VVTi still on the 5,000 km sched or at 10,000km? If it is at 10k km, then the savings drop to about 3,750 pesos per 5,000 km.

Which means you'll have to drive at least 30-40k km a year to make back the cost difference between getting the gas and the diesel.

Pero with the possible pump problems you'll get with the diesel once you're past warranty, and the fact that it's a turbo (I think), will mean relatively more maintenance costs after three years than the gas variant, which will have steady maintenance costs over five to seven years.

Awesome analysis...

[FrankDrebin]

Ay, additional:

Every 5000 km, your diesel costs will be around 16,000 pesos (given urban traffic), at about 10 km/l.

Every 5000 km, your gasoline costs will be around 23,000 pesos (given urban traffic), at about 8 km/l.

A 5000km checkup for a 2.5 liter diesel vehicle will cost you around 4500 (dunno if the Innova is the same), while the 5000km checkup for a 2.0 gas vehicle costs around 2500.

Total cost per 5000 km is around 20,500 for diesel, and 25,500 for gas. You save about 5,000 pesos for every 5,000 km, or about 1 peso per kilometer with the diesel version. That's merely a rough estimate, mind you.

I don't know how much the price difference between gas and diesel variants is, but that also factors into your decision making.

Hey, for anybody who knows, is the Innova VVTi still on the 5,000 km sched or at 10,000km? If it is at 10k km, then the savings drop to about 3,750 pesos per 5,000 km.

Which means you'll have to drive at least 30-40k km a year to make back the cost difference between getting the gas and the diesel.

Pero with the possible pump problems you'll get with the diesel once you're past warranty, and the fact that it's a turbo (I think), will mean relatively more maintenance costs after three years than the gas variant, which will have steady maintenance costs over five to seven years.

Hehehe. Kapag sa Casa ang service mahal talaga. Regarding sa Diesel at Gasoline Maintenance. Siguro depende sa Diesel engine. Like that of Isuzu (Highlander) 5000PMS, I only spend around P2K-3K. That is only 4 liters of oil and little oil filter unlike those of Mitsu's 4D56 gigantor filters and 6 liters of oil. Since truck-based naman ang Innova, expect na mas matibay ang underchassis niya unlike sa mga cars. Also, please bear in mind that Gasoline engines are composed of many parts like sensors thingies like computer box, O2, MAF, etc. In short, many parts means many to replace.

To answer the question, go for the Innova Gas. :D

[acenie]

From the Previous bad experience of the D4D 2.5 Innova!
For me I'll go for GAS.

[slamtaz]

hoon, i guess niky has covered all of the more practical side between your choices...

[IIE]

i go for gas.....

[XTO]

imo gas variant would be fine considering the d-4d's arising problems concerning phil diesel quality. a 2.0 vvt-i 100+hp gas is perfect for it's body.

[red_wagen]

I think gas is best...

[niky]

That's 126-135 hp, I think, dahil VVTi. Yes, it's a nice choice. :D

[wakin]

gas po ang suggestion ko...Im also in the same situation as yours, I will be getting my innova next week.

[arvic]

If you want to test your patience go for diesel(d4d prob) otherwise go for Gasoline.