SUVs do poorly in rollover resistance ratings

[Djerms]

Boybi,
Kung sa category ng collision, panalo talaga ang mga SUV's. Hindi naman kasi dapat pinangkakarera ito coz prone talaga to rollover ang mga ito.

Nung nabangga ang trooper namin sabi ng dad ko mabuti nalang at trooper ang dala ko. Kung car yun or a small pick-up, baka nasaktan kami. Hehe upon impact dun sa trooper, alam ko na malakas kasi narinig ko ung impact sa body eh. But hindi ko masyado na feel. Parang nalubak lang. Hehe

[Litespeed]

BMW X5 three stars lang? :confused: Ouch... don't tell this to my wife. Ang selling pitch ko sa kanya ay SAFETY of this truck. Oh well, BMW call this SAV. Not really meant for hardcore offroading. I still love my X5, though

[pissword]

sino ba ayaw ng X5 hehehe... uhhmmm d ko lam pero it doesnt matter that much namn eh just drive safely. kasi kahit anung safety whatever pa yan dyan pag balasubas ka tlaga magdrive tlagang d safe. pero may advantage nga ang SUV kasi most vehicles on the road naman are cars lang eh... so mas safe ka in a way

[Litespeed]

BTW, may group dito sa US lobbying the congress to discontinue productions of SUV's like Navigators and Expeditions due to the same reason na people on the other smaller vehicles fatalities. Not to mention na nagpapa-alila ang US sa middle east oil.
Ford Excursion was discontinue only after 1 year of production. Poor sales.

[OTEP]

Originally posted by badsekktor
ganun ba? eh ano naman ang use ng mga suv's? kung may mga auv's na better sa floods at di maganda ratings sa safety, ano na silbi ng mga suv's? design lang ba ang mga to?

For me they are used as work trucks and off-road toys. These vehicles are not fashion accessories so you better treat them as they are.

Macky,

GEN III ok naman ang crash rating. Pero GEN II (yung sakin) mababa talaga lalo na sa IIHS at NCAP.

[mazdamazda]

there was a talk that should the US stop selling SUVs, they wouldn't have to import oil anymore...

anyway, we had a Rav4 for the following things:

- soft off road capability for use when the going gets rough
- ability to transport a lot of goodies
- extra ground clearance
- pogi points! :D

but we also have to know the limits of SUVs, even in the user's manual they pointed out that there is a high risk of rolling over. so they shouldn't be driven around corners like a sedan.

[AC]

i respectfuli disagree po... suvs are safer po... compared to cars... thats the reason y pipol buy them po... as long as ndi ka hahataw ng mala circuit... i think maliit lang ang chansa mong mag roll.... nakita ko na kasi nangyari sa tamaraw fx and a pajero na nagbangaan eh.. yung fx durog... while yung pajero very minimal damage... the fx was hit from behind by the pajero... for sure dederetso na yun sa talyer... ndi lang nakupi but pati yung korte umiba eh... i think safer lang ang fx compared sa corollas dahil sa height nito but if it were only as low as corollas... baka mas matibay pa po mga corolla... kaya.. i dont think pipol buy SUVs for japorms lang po... if u love life... gusto mo syempre safe ka and ur family.. yun lang po... peace po hehe btw i think SUVs are tougher than vans, auvs, compact and midsize cars and somepickups po...

[OTEP]

SUV's have lower ratings when it comes to laboratory crash testing. Sa lab kasi, the tests are done so as to mimic a Pajero crashing into another Pajero. So weight and height are out of the equation na. What is being tested is how well the vehicle's structure will hold up.

Sadly, it doesn't hold up very well. And the crash test dummies tend to hit a lot of hard spots in the vehicle cabin which could lead to head injuries and other stuff.

[20vanda01]

I think whether your ride is a car or an SUV or an AUV or bus, it will still depend on the event of the accident. Anyway, the key here is everybody does drive safely, then it will be safer for everybody. At kung mataas ang EQ (emotional quotient) ng mga drivers, malamang walang magmumurahan at magbubusinahan sa daan.

[sir_jeep]

Sa US ginawa at based doon yung tests di ba? This only proves that driver's there are not as good as compared here in our country hehehehehe........ Kung dito ginawa yung tests malaki ang posibilidad na mataas ang rating ng SUV's, whether it's a rollover resistance test or safety tests. Magaling kasi ang pinoy magdala ng sasakyan. Kahit ano kayang i-drive hehehehehe......... opinion lang po............:-)

[mazdamazda]

roll-over resistance is just part and parcel of the overall safety performance of a vehicle...

[mbt]

sir_jeep,

one thing going for american drivers is that they're DISCIPLINED though...

madaling iinterpret yung "magaling magdala ng sasakyan ang pinoy" as reckless driving hehehe

[OTEP]

sir_jeep,

Wala pong driver ang sasakyan during government crash tests and rollover tests. Para one less variable in the equation.

[Bubbles]

MBT tama ka diyan. Pero, katangahan nila is that they expect an SUV to drive and perform like a ferarri. How many pajeros have rolled over here in Pinas? How many explorers have you seen turned turtle in Pinas? You see it in movies, big American SUV's driven like cars in chase scenes. One thing to understand, its not the same in the real world. You can't fishtail an exped/suburban/etc. just like that and expect to survive...

[pissword]

hehehe kita mo nga o kung safety concerns lang ang paguusapan dapat lahat ng jeepney eh ban na sa daan..d na sila sasakyan minsan road hazard na.. hehe pati un mga driver kasing bulok minsan kakainis.

going back to the topic, oo nga sir bubbles, kaya nga may iba ibang klase ng sasakyan, para din sa ibat ibang klase ng purpose

[sir_jeep]

Originally posted by mbt
sir_jeep,

one thing going for american drivers is that they're DISCIPLINED though...

madaling iinterpret yung "magaling magdala ng sasakyan ang pinoy" as reckless driving hehehe

Tumpak kayo dyan sir................... hehehehe

[sir_jeep]

Originally posted by OTEP
sir_jeep,

Wala pong driver ang sasakyan during government crash tests and rollover tests. Para one less variable in the equation.

Good point sir............ missing variable nga po yung walang "live" driver............. bakit kaya nung nag-test ng rocket gumamit ng unggoy (unggoy nga ba hehehe?) tapos yung mga test aircraft na ginawa nila unggoy din ginamit hmmmmmmmn.............. hehehehe napaisip lang po ako............

[ipsgmole21]

Go0d choice base on your purpose.Good interior pero among the compact SUVs napag-iwanan n cya.Pero whats important you enjoy using it

[mikey177]

I was browsing the NHSTA web site and I discovered some things I never knew, like

• Nearly 75% of all rollover crashes occur in rural areas (great... araw-araw pa naman ako bumabiyahe sa McArthur Highway)
• If you're using a roof rack, pay special attention to the manufacturer's instructions and weight limits. Any load placed on the roof will be above the vehicle's center of gravity, and will increase the vehicle's likelihood of rolling over

[tagalnasaabroad]

roll-over resistance issue..? i looked at it as a deterrent to drive more safely and sensibly..kahit na anong configuration pa ng sasakyan pag hinarurut mo without regards to road terrain and inherent conditions, tataob ka talaga..!