Who would win? Imperial Star Destroyer vs Enterprise D

[ghosthunter]

Who would win? Imperial Star Destroyer vs Enterprise D

[Mguy]

I would equate this to a battleship versus an aircraft carrier.

[vinj]

Sama niyo na rin si Millenium Falcon.

[CVT]

Sama niyo na rin si Millenium Falcon.

Maliit lang si Millenium Falcon, bro.... Pero siyempre, nakasilat din ng isang Imperial Star Destroyer....

Ako, sa USS Enterprise,- mayroon na yatang cloaking device iyan, di ba?

16.6K:sunny::sampay:

[Monseratto]

The Star Destroyer can use its TIE Fighters and Bombers out of range of Enterprise D main weapons. I'm not sure if Enterprise have CIWS that can defeat small multiple targets...

[CVT]

The Star Destroyer can use its TIE Fighters and Bombers out of range of Enterprise D main weapons. I'm not sure if Enterprise have CIWS that can defeat small multiple targets...

Tama ka naman diyan, bro....

Baka mas magandang match ay iyong BattleStar Galactica?...

16.6K:sunny::sampay:

[ghosthunter]

Ako, sa USS Enterprise,- mayroon na yatang cloaking device iyan, di ba?

16.6K:sunny::sampay:

Wala cloaking device yung Federations. Only Klingons & Romulans have cloaking tech.

[ghosthunter]

Tama ka naman diyan, bro....

Baka mas magandang match ay iyong BattleStar Galactica?...

16.6K:sunny::sampay:

Kung Battlestar Galactica, talo yung Battlestar because they do not have shield technology. Battlestars are a combination heavy battleship with aircraft carrier. They have heavy armor but no shields. So a direct hit on any critical section would disable or destroy it.

So a Battlestar is no match for either an Imperial Star Destroyer or Federation Galaxy-class starship.

[ghosthunter]

The Star Destroyer can use its TIE Fighters and Bombers out of range of Enterprise D main weapons. I'm not sure if Enterprise have CIWS that can defeat small multiple targets...

Tie fighters cannot penetrate the Enterprise's main shields.

And given tie fighters do not have shields, Enterprise can teleport the tie fighter pilots away from their respective fighters.

[Monseratto]

Tie fighters cannot penetrate the Enterprise's main shields.

And given tie fighters do not have shields, Enterprise can teleport the tie fighter pilots away from their respective fighters.

The Dark Sith can use the force on the crew of the Enterprise to lower their shields...hehehe. Next subject Gundams vs Transformers....

[ZENMasterTYL]

uubra ba ang battlecruiser dyan

[Altis6453]

Using what's known as the "Picard Maneuver", the Enterprise D would accelerate at Warp 9 or maximum warp directly against an Imperial Destroyer. The Imperial Destroyer won't be able to detect the Enterprise D until it had dropped out of warp right behind it and launched its full arsenal of phasers and photon torpedoes against the Imperial Destroyer. Game over.

[niky]

The Enterprise only has two main weapons and no adjunct fighters. It could probably hold its own against the better armed Imperial Star Destroyer... since those seem made of cardboard... but against Vader's... I doubt it.

[ghosthunter]

The Dark Sith can use the force on the crew of the Enterprise to lower their shields...hehehe.

But even the "Force" mind techniques has a limited range.

My favorite way for the enterprise to win... teleport a photon torpedo into their bridge. LOL!

[ghosthunter]

The Enterprise only has two main weapons and no adjunct fighters. It could probably hold its own against the better armed Imperial Star Destroyer... since those seem made of cardboard... but against Vader's... I doubt it.

The only thing the Enterprise has to do is concentrate it's phaser barrage at the two spheres on the Star Destroyer. Those are the shield generators for Star Destroyers. Without them, the Star Destroyer will be junk in a minute.

The Enterprise may have only two main weapons (phaser emitter arrays and torpedoes) but it also has it's teleporter which is a very flexible tool to enhance a ship's options of attack. One way to use the teleporter is to beam aboard a boarding crew in a critical/vulnerable location of the target ship (example, engine room). Second use for the teleporter is to beam an explosive device right into the middle of the target ship. Third option for the teleporter, beam out vital components of the target ship into space (example: entire bridge crew or vital engine part).

:evil:

[safeorigin]

Still waiting for OB's insight

[Monseratto]

The only thing the Enterprise has to do is concentrate it's phaser barrage at the two spheres on the Star Destroyer. Those are the shield generators for Star Destroyers. Without them, the Star Destroyer will be junk in a minute.

The Enterprise may have only two main weapons (phaser emitter arrays and torpedoes) but it also has it's teleporter which is a very flexible tool to enhance a ship's options of attack. One way to use the teleporter is to beam aboard a boarding crew in a critical/vulnerable location of the target ship (example, engine room). Second use for the teleporter is to beam an explosive device right into the middle of the target ship. Third option for the teleporter, beam out vital components of the target ship into space (example: entire bridge crew or vital engine part).

:evil:

Why they never did that to the Borg is beyond me...

In fact that what happened in First Contact, it was the Borg who teleported to the Enterprise and nearly assimilated the entire crew.

[CVT]

The only thing the Enterprise has to do is concentrate it's phaser barrage at the two spheres on the Star Destroyer. Those are the shield generators for Star Destroyers. Without them, the Star Destroyer will be junk in a minute.

The Enterprise may have only two main weapons (phaser emitter arrays and torpedoes) but it also has it's teleporter which is a very flexible tool to enhance a ship's options of attack. One way to use the teleporter is to beam aboard a boarding crew in a critical/vulnerable location of the target ship (example, engine room). Second use for the teleporter is to beam an explosive device right into the middle of the target ship. Third option for the teleporter, beam out vital components of the target ship into space (example: entire bridge crew or vital engine part).

:evil:

Yup, a matter-antimatter canister with a timer and then, boom... :boom:

16.6K:sunny::sampay:

[niky]

A teleporter will not work through shields. While it will work on unshielded TIE fighters and bombers, the calculations needed to hit a moving target with a highly variable vector are complex. It already takes a while to lock onto another main ship or planet (as per the novels). Locking onto a dodging and weaving TIE fighter may be next to impossible.

The Enterprise's antimatter core would be a potent weapon. It's something Star Wras ships would not be able to defend against.

[CVT]

Di ba nga't naituro na ni (future) Spock kay Chekov ang pagte-teleport even at warp speed?

E di yakang-yaka nang i-teleport ang matter-antimatter canister sa Imperial Star Destroyer kahit na naka hyperdrive ito...

16.6K:sunny::sampay: