No Right Turn on Red Signal

[bongsta008]

Pwede ba hulihin ang isang vehicle na mag right turn on red signal kahit wala namang sign na "no right turn on red signal?"

Let's say you made a right turn with caution. Then suddenly may nakaabang na MAPSA, police or MMDA tapos hinuli ka.

I don't think there is any written ordinance na pwede nila i-apprehend yung driver. Correct me if I'm wrong. I also don't think na violation yun.

I have been pulled over several times. To site some of them.... one was in Ayala cor Edsa when making a right turn going towards the south. Another was in Herrera St. in Makati making a right turn to Dela Rosa St.

[speed_lab]

dapat po meron nakalagay "turn right anytime with caution".

[blacksun25]

usually mariming ganyan sa makati. kaya ingat na lang. ilang beses na rin ako nahuli niyan. kaya medyo praning na rin ako. i don't turn right not unless green na ang traffic light.

when you get apprehended for such violation. ask them to show you where the "no right turn on red signal" sign is. if there isn't one, then you may contest it.

[ans_lim168]

there should be a sign that prohibits right turn when the signal is red....sad to say enforcers use this as a means to apprehend motorists...what I do is I don't take chances when I need to make a right turn I just wait for the signal to turn green...never mind the delay than ending up with a useless debate with an enforcer...like what blacksun posted you may contest this but then again you should make yourself free to appear and attend the hearing to contest the violation.

[mbeige]

If there is indeed a sign, I would take out the camera and snap a few shots of how visible it really is, if it's an official sign, if it's covered by trees, posts, etc, and forward it to whoever you're going to complain to.

If there's no sign that says you can't make a right turn on red, then you've just been pulled over for no reason.

[ronw123w124]

Pagnagpumilit na parahin ka ng mga MOKONG na yan, tumabi ka, pag hingi ng DL mo pakita mo pero WAG mo bigay dahil once na binigay mo DL pagpipilitan na nila na violation mo kahit wala naman sign in the 1st place or gagawan ka ng kung anu-anong traffic violation para MAKOTONGAN ka lang. Just argue you're way anyway hindi ka nila pwede bigyan ng ticket since hindi mo naman bigay DL mo. It works for me.

[bongsta008]

It's just sad kasi wala talagang standard at maayos na systema ang bansang to. We always have to keep on second guessing kung bawal o hindi. Walang malinaw na kasulatan. Sana one day everything will be in black and white and standard para hindi iba iba ang sinusundan nating motorists.

I forgot to mention nga pala nung nahuli ako dun sa edsa, yung sinundan kong Ford Expedition hindi hinuli. Siguro natakot kasi baka bigtime yung huhulihin nila. Kainis talaga.

[Esnie.com]

Pwede ba hulihin ang isang vehicle na mag right turn on red signal kahit wala namang sign na "no right turn on red signal?"

Let's say you made a right turn with caution. Then suddenly may nakaabang na MAPSA, police or MMDA tapos hinuli ka.

I don't think there is any written ordinance na pwede nila i-apprehend yung driver. Correct me if I'm wrong. I also don't think na violation yun.

I have been pulled over several times. To site some of them.... one was in Ayala cor Edsa when making a right turn going towards the south. Another was in Herrera St. in Makati making a right turn to Dela Rosa St.

Dapat hindi ka huhulihin kasi walang signage na nakalagay. kung nag-insist pa din sila na kahit walang nakalagay ay dapat hindi pa din aba.... ISA lang ang habol nila ang MANGOTONG.

kunin mo pangalan nila at ISUMBONG KAY TULFO!

[dennis powell]

as ong as walang sign na no right turn on red,eh hindi ka dapat hulihin,sana hinanapan mo sila ng traffic order kung kasama ba dun ang no right turn on red sa espisipikong lugar na iyon,palagay ko ang napasukan mo ay "no rite tong on red"kaya nahuli ka.

[chiekot]

Pwede ba hulihin ang isang vehicle na mag right turn on red signal kahit wala namang sign na "no right turn on red signal?"

Let's say you made a right turn with caution. Then suddenly may nakaabang na MAPSA, police or MMDA tapos hinuli ka.

I don't think there is any written ordinance na pwede nila i-apprehend yung driver. Correct me if I'm wrong. I also don't think na violation yun.

I have been pulled over several times. To site some of them.... one was in Ayala cor Edsa when making a right turn going towards the south. Another was in Herrera St. in Makati making a right turn to Dela Rosa St.

Buhayin ko lang ito kasi until now ay gawain parin nila ito.

Nangyari sa akin ito sa Fairview, QC. just yeterday. Coming from FEU Hospital via Regalado Ave., nag right turn ako to Commonwealth Ave. while on red signal. I have not noticed any sign that would stop me from doing that, pero may mga nakaabang na palang 5 traffic enforcer at pinilit akong tikitan. tinanong ko kung anong violation at ang sabi nga ay bawal daw ginawa ko. So, apologize na hindi ko napansin kung may sign sa kanto. Pero ang tono ng enforcer ay tipong nanghihingi na ng kotong. I insist na ipakita sa akin ang sign na bawal mag right turn dun bago niya ako tikitan. Hindi na siya nakipagtalo at isinoli na lang ang DL ko. Ni-singko wala siyang nakuha sa akin. Kotong lang pala habol nyo mga taran....!

Moral lesson... dapat aware ka sa mga traffic rules and regulations kundi talagang makokotongan ka.

[holdencaulfield]

sa totoo lang pag makipot yung kalye at alanganin at main thoroughfare dapat mag right turn lang

pag go na signal.

t*ngina, cause ng trapik at delikado yung ginagawa ng iba.

right of way mo at go mapapamenor ka dahil may mga kupal na ipipilit kumanan. buti kamo kung

inner right lang yung sasakupin. eh magsiswerve pa kamo sa kaliwa.

at sa dami ng gustong

kumanan, hayup, nag rambol na!

[CVT]

Iyan kasi ang tinatawag na unprotected right turn,- o right turn with caution....

Dapat, ang magra-right turn ang magyi-yield or siya ang second priority....

Ang problema sa mga Pinoy drivers,- gusto siya palagi ang priority,- kaya itong basic traffic discipline ay hindi nasusunod, katulad din ng "keep intersection open" or "zebra zone"

Katulad sa isang intersection na walang left turn signal ang traffic light,- anyone can turn left if his lane is green,- BUT with caution... Ang kaso,- either gusto niyang siya ang priority or ayaw ng kasalubong niya to keep the intersection open,- kaya this basic traffic discipline will not work here.... Kailangan tuloy ng left turn signal sa traffic light.....


“The measure of a man is what he does with power – LJIOHF!”
24.4K:sailor:

[IMm29]

Iyan kasi ang tinatawag na unprotected right turn,- o right turn with caution....

Dapat, ang magra-right turn ang magyi-yield or siya ang second priority....

Ang problema sa mga Pinoy drivers,- gusto siya palagi ang priority,- kaya itong basic traffic discipline ay hindi nasusunod, katulad din ng "keep intersection open" or "zebra zone"

Katulad sa isang intersection na walang left turn signal ang traffic light,- anyone can turn left if his lane is green,- BUT with caution... Ang kaso,- either gusto niyang siya ang priority or ayaw ng kasalubong niya to keep the intersection open,- kaya this basic traffic discipline will not work here.... Kailangan tuloy ng left turn signal sa traffic light.....


“The measure of a man is what he does with power – LJIOHF!”
24.4K:sailor:

Well, this is when you've given everyone enough of a chance to change on their own and nothing is improving. Time to bring in the cops and do enforcement.

Thing is, where can we find the non-crooked cops who know the law and how to implement the law?

[CVT]

Well, this is when you've given everyone enough of a chance to change on their own and nothing is improving. Time to bring in the cops and do enforcement.

Thing is, where can we find the non-crooked cops who know the law and how to implement the law?

Iyon nga ang problema bro,- dahil sa kawalan ng disiplina ng mga drivers dito sa ating bansa :

1. Nagkakaroon tuloy ng mga ganyang signs sa kalye (no right turn on red or right turn only on green o keep intersection open) - kurakot iyan sa signages

2. Nadaragdagan ang mga traffic enforcers sa intersection na hindi naman dapat kailangan - pakaway kaway lang naman at palaging nasa ilalim ng shade na ang gusto lang gawin ay manghuli at hindi sumuporta sa traffic sa intersection - meaning i guide ang mga motorista. On the other side, kung medyo sinisipag at gustong dumiskate,- aba e ino-override ang traffic light na mali naman,- patayin na lang kung gusto nilang sila ang magmando ng traffic >>> dagdag pasweldo pa ang mga iyan,- source ng kurakot - hindi alam ng lahat ng traffic enforcers ang basic traffic law/discipline,- source din ng traffic dahil sa pagpa-para ng mga sasakyan at makikipagtalo sa gitna ng kalye - mano'ng patabihin at malayo sa intersection - doon sila mag-usap.....

3. Iyong mga gusto ng disiplina sa kalye,- nalulunod ng katarant*duh*n ng maraming fellow drivers sa atin... Gusto mong "keep the intersection open"- e lahat nagsa-swapang na mauna kahit na hinto na ang lane nila at blocked na ang intersection.... Bubusinahan ka pa at sisigawang,- mahinang kang driver!!!.......Ang mga traffic enforcers?,- wala lang,- kaway lang ng kaway o kamot ulo..... Ang bo-b*b*.... Hay naku! Labu-labo na lang... "The first one who blinks- gives way"... langya...



“The measure of a man is what he does with power – LJIOHF!”
24.4K:sailor:

[Manilablock]

Madalas sa Makati ung asa likod ko puro busina, kasi pag hindi green or nag senyas un nangongotong na pwede ako kumanan.

Pwede ka ba ticketan kung hindi ka kumanan (while red ang traf light) if other drivers are doing it.

sent via LaTE Network

[e2romo]

Sa traffic law pwede kang mag right turn kahit pula unless may sign na nagbabawal. Kung walang sign understood na pwede. Sa traffic rule din kung sino nasa main road ang may right of way. Kung red light sa atin you have to wait till it's safe to turn, kung ipinilit mong ipasok ng red ang traffic signal mo at nabangga ka ang lamang sa kaso ay yung green light. They would be travelling fast with the expectation na walang papasok sa kanan dahil green ang light nila, they know those on red will yield to them as per traffic law.

[yobma]

OT: Hehe goes to show us Filipinos are still so naive about traffic rules... not all ofcourse but a good majority... kanya kanyang interpretation. Nakakatawa but theres some truth to the joke daw na for filipinos... traffic lights and traffic rules are just 'suggestion'... pag hindi nahuli... puede..

Seriously though i apply the rule na when in doubt (like no signage) i follow the traffic light. Better to err on the side of caution... rather than argue with a traffic officer...

Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[jut703]

Personally I think the signs are clear, but the law enforcement isn't.

No right on red is self-explanatory. Same with right/left turn must turn right/left. Combining them is an "and" statement so you can't go straight if you're on the rightmost or leftmost lane, and you can't complete your turn until the stoplight says green.

However, MMDA and LGU enforcers don't seem to understand this very well, or are being very selective about it.

Case in point: intersection of Julia Vargas and Meralco Ave.

If you're coming from Megamall, traversing J. Vargas towards Tiendesitas, the leftmost lane is exclusive for vehicles turning left. If you go straight, your friendly neighborhood enforcer is waiting for you.

Now, on the opposite direction (coming from Tiendesitas going to Megamall), you can stay on the leftmost lane but not turn left to Meralco and instead go straight.

Both directions are of equal width, so lane clogging isn't supposed to be different.


Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[leodawesome]

What we need here are steel bumpers and dashcams, OR patience. Kahit stoplight di naman sinusunod. Napapadalas na yung humahabol kahit red light na, and I'm talking about private vehicles.

Kapag sira naman yung stoplight, it means 'infinite GO'. :rofl01:

[Aoshinomori]

No Right Turn on Red Signal

Kapag walang sign, mas ok mag ingat at huwag nang dumeretso.
Next, kapag may stoplight sa kanan at red light ito, hindi dapat kumanan.
Usually may nakalagay pag puwede kumanan on red light.
Kapag nasa Pilipinas, jeep/tricycle/bus/motorcycle ay puwedeng i-disregard lahat ng rules. Proven na ito as per my experience. Huwag basta susunod kapag PUV ang kumanan.