
Originally Posted by
oj88
Using an alternator not meant for your car model is a hit or miss thing. Unless you know the trade, it's usually not worth the headache later.
Case in point, my kid brother's Hyundai Getz broke down due to a faulty alternator (dead rectifier/regulator module, to be exact). Being a non-techie, he went ahead with the Banawe technician's suggestion of using a used alternator from a Hyundai Besta. It charged the battery alright and for the most part, it did its job. However, we started noticing that the engine idles funny when we switch on the hazard lights. We later concluded that this is likely an incompatibility between the engine's ECU/electrical load sensor (if equipped) and the field coil. He shelled out about 4k for everything but only got to use the replacement alternator for 6-7 months before it too, died.
With my influence, we decided to go with a brand new OEM alternator and the car has been running ever so smoothly since last November. Expensive, but well worth it.
OT: Funny thing with my bro's Getz... the battery warning idiot lamp did not light up during the two incidents the alternator conked out. But the idiot lamp works with the ignition on and the engine off. Go figure. As a workaround, I just got him a 700-peso cigarette lighter plug-in voltmeter. I just told him that if the voltage goes below 12V with the engine running and all accessories turned off, drive it to the nearest gas station, just to be on the safe side.