X-trail or CRV?

[dhisky]

My sister is planning to buy a CUV.

She's confused between the new Xtrail (4x2 CVT) and the CRV (V AT). Di nagkakalayo ng price.

Medyo bias ako sa pag influence sa kanya to get the CRV since I own a honda pero I'm not sure about the new X-trail if there's any issue.

Mostly city driving lang and mga twice a month out of town. Manila to Quezon. 3 passenger lang lagi sakay.

I hope to get your opinion on these on which is better.

-Looks (subjective but will surely help)
-FC
-Ride comfort

Thanks!

[StockEngine]

Mazda cx5 ayaw nya? Cx5 has had no issues since 2013. Meron na ata discounts like last year?

[dhisky]

Mazda cx5 ayaw nya? Cx5 has had no issues since 2013. Meron na ata discounts like last year?

Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Mazda cx5 ayaw nya? Cx5 has had no issues since 2013. Meron na ata discounts like last year?

Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

[niky]

Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -



Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

According to who?

None of your choices are particularly fuel efficient in the city. And the X-Trail and CR-V (from the times I've driven them) are a step behind the CX-5 in city traffic, especially if you're talking about a CX-5 variant with i-Stop.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -



Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

According to who?

None of your choices are particularly fuel efficient in the city. And the X-Trail and CR-V (from the times I've driven them) are a step behind the CX-5 in city traffic, especially if you're talking about a CX-5 variant with i-Stop.

[StockEngine]

Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -



Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

cx-5 has the best fC in this segment.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -



Sir di ata ok FC ng CX5 sa city driving? pero highway ok daw not sure though.

cx-5 has the best fC in this segment.

[minicarph]

X-Trail para mukang SUV talaga

[yebo]

Cx5 has had no issues since 2013.

meron kaya issue transmission nyan. 3 na nakasabay ko sa mazda quezon ave na pabalik-balik din kasi may sira tranny ng new cx5 nila. nagthreaten na nga ng demanda yung last na nakausap ko e. meron yung ayaw mag shift, yung 2 nawawalan ng power naka 5000 rpm na daw makina di maka-akyat sa ramp.

[ClaNker]

meron kaya issue transmission nyan. 3 na nakasabay ko sa mazda quezon ave na pabalik-balik din kasi may sira tranny ng new cx5 nila. nagthreaten na nga ng demanda yung last na nakausap ko e. meron yung ayaw mag shift, yung 2 nawawalan ng power naka 5000 rpm na daw makina di maka-akyat sa ramp.

Yikes!

X-trail ako.

[dhisky]

Thanks for suggesting CX5 pero decided na sister ko between the two lang...

She's 70% with X-trail na kaya lang since new generation ito baka may mga issues na lumabas...

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Thanks for suggesting CX5 pero decided na sister ko between the two lang...

She's 70% with X-trail na kaya lang since new generation ito baka may mga issues na lumabas...

[jesqatar]

Thanks for suggesting CX5 pero decided na sister ko between the two lang...

She's 70% with X-trail na kaya lang since new generation ito baka may mga issues na lumabas...

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Thanks for suggesting CX5 pero decided na sister ko between the two lang...

She's 70% with X-trail na kaya lang since new generation ito baka may mga issues na lumabas...

Go for X-trail marami yan dito sa middle east.....its a mini nissan pathfinder looks...

[Head-On]

+1 sa xtrail for looks alone. Haven't researched and test drove both. HTH

[minicarph]

So many xtrails in Tokyo, it's particularly popular in Akihabara, dami young Japs with that car

[Wh1stl3r2]

CX-5 is great to drive but I think the stiffest ride. I don't trust the start/stop system. It might lead to premature wear in the long run.

As for the 2 choices:
Looks - Xtrail
FC - more or less the same
Ride comfort - For long drives on-road: Xtrail
For the rougher stuff: CR-V. Xtrail seats are better for me but the CR-V's suspension is softer.

[Princy]

We both have the CRV 4WD Japan CBU and X-Trail 4x4.

Si misis mas gustong gamit and CRV kasi may blind spot ang X-Trail at nalalaparan sya hence nahihirapan sya sa parking.
Sa FC malakas lang ng konti and CRV (6.6km/L), X-trail (7.8km/l) average city/highway consumption.
Handling mas Ok ang CRV.
Riding comfort sa akin mas Ok CRV pero kay misis X-Trail.
Other features mas Ok ang X-trail.

[sientobente]

Being an owner of the current-gen CRV, I am pretty happy with my purchase and I don't have any regrets owning it.

I bought my CRV around the same time last year. Compared this to the RAV4 base, Forester base, XV Premium and the CX5 2.0 2WD. Feature by feature, it beats them all. Mine is the Modulo CRV. It has rear AC vents, Cruise Control, LCD/MID, Tonneau cover(not all CUVs or dealers have this for free), One-touch fold for rear seats, my dealer also threw in free parking sensors and a 3M tint, Best interior space(leg, shoulder and cargo space) plus many more.

Fuel consumption too is much better than the previous CRV generations. I can get 8.6kms/liter * 22kph average speed(moderate traffic). In comparison, my Monty GLS 2WD averages 7.9kms/liter on same average speed.

Note: We already compared the difference between the MID and manual computation. The variance falls between +/- .1 to .2 kms/liter only.

We also went to Baguio a couple of months ago. From Pasig to Baguio(via Nlex/Sctex/Tplex), my Fuel Consumption was 13kms/liter with the Econ button off. It was higher going down from Baguio where I averaged 14.5kms/liter.

So, against the X-Trail? I kinda won't consider a Nissan, specially with the numerous problems my parents had with their Y61 Patrol with local dealers here. Plus the base Xtrail is as bare as it can be.

[dhisky]

Being an owner of the current-gen CRV, I am pretty happy with my purchase and I don't have any regrets owning it.

I bought my CRV around the same time last year. Compared this to the RAV4 base, Forester base, XV Premium and the CX5 2.0 2WD. Feature by feature, it beats them all. Mine is the Modulo CRV. It has rear AC vents, Cruise Control, LCD/MID, Tonneau cover(not all CUVs or dealers have this for free), One-touch fold for rear seats, my dealer also threw in free parking sensors and a 3M tint, Best interior space(leg, shoulder and cargo space) plus many more.

Fuel consumption too is much better than the previous CRV generations. I can get 8.6kms/liter * 22kph average speed(moderate traffic). In comparison, my Monty GLS 2WD averages 7.9kms/liter on same average speed.

Note: We already compared the difference between the MID and manual computation. The variance falls between +/- .1 to .2 kms/liter only.

We also went to Baguio a couple of months ago. From Pasig to Baguio(via Nlex/Sctex/Tplex), my Fuel Consumption was 13kms/liter with the Econ button off. It was higher going down from Baguio where I averaged 14.5kms/liter.

So, against the X-Trail? I kinda won't consider a Nissan, specially with the numerous problems my parents had with their Y61 Patrol with local dealers here. Plus the base Xtrail is as bare as it can be.

Thank you guys sa feedback!

Concern lang sa CRV is, may lalabas na bang new generation?

Yung current generation what year nag start?

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Being an owner of the current-gen CRV, I am pretty happy with my purchase and I don't have any regrets owning it.

I bought my CRV around the same time last year. Compared this to the RAV4 base, Forester base, XV Premium and the CX5 2.0 2WD. Feature by feature, it beats them all. Mine is the Modulo CRV. It has rear AC vents, Cruise Control, LCD/MID, Tonneau cover(not all CUVs or dealers have this for free), One-touch fold for rear seats, my dealer also threw in free parking sensors and a 3M tint, Best interior space(leg, shoulder and cargo space) plus many more.

Fuel consumption too is much better than the previous CRV generations. I can get 8.6kms/liter * 22kph average speed(moderate traffic). In comparison, my Monty GLS 2WD averages 7.9kms/liter on same average speed.

Note: We already compared the difference between the MID and manual computation. The variance falls between +/- .1 to .2 kms/liter only.

We also went to Baguio a couple of months ago. From Pasig to Baguio(via Nlex/Sctex/Tplex), my Fuel Consumption was 13kms/liter with the Econ button off. It was higher going down from Baguio where I averaged 14.5kms/liter.

So, against the X-Trail? I kinda won't consider a Nissan, specially with the numerous problems my parents had with their Y61 Patrol with local dealers here. Plus the base Xtrail is as bare as it can be.

Thank you guys sa feedback!

Concern lang sa CRV is, may lalabas na bang new generation?

Yung current generation what year nag start?

[Egan101]

I like the looks of the Xtrail over the CRV. The XTrail is the only one in its category to have a standard foldable 3rd row seat. Given the choice though, I will choose between the Forester or CX5.

[dct]

Xtrail for me. Dapat due na ang crv sa new model or new facelift di ba? 2012 pa ata yan. Xtrail bago pa lang

[StockEngine]

With the bad traffic i dont think the xtrail will achieve over 8km/l in the metro. More in the 4-6km/liter range.

I think they will release a new small turbo version in 2016. Which will be more frugal in the city.

[dhisky]

every 10k/6 months din ba PMS ng Nissan?