Used 2012 Fiesta Sports + 1.6 vs Jazz 1.5 AT

**LucasVN** · March 5th, 2015 01:53 AM

Hi guys,

Planning to get a smaller vehicle to replace my compact SUV to a more practical one, I have the two options in mind:

1. 2012 Ford Fiesta Sports +

Good Points:

- Good Addons (Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Skirts, Spoilers, Audio Controls on Steering)
- Low Mileage (Mileage 10-15K Kms Only)
- Good Price

Bad Points:

- Transmission Issues (shuddering issues even on new models)

2. 2012 Honda Jazz 1.5 AT

Good Points:

- Space
- No known serious issues (That I know of)

Bad Points:

- NO Bluetooth, No Audito Controls on Steering Wheel
- High Mileage (30-35K Kms)
- Price (50-80K more)

I used to own a Jazz before (GD) and it served me very well. My questions is what would you choose from the two? Is the Transmission Issues on Fiesta a major concern? or since it is covered by warranty, but it is worth the hassle? The 50-80K additional on Jazz worth it?

Thanks in advance.

**jut703** · March 5th, 2015 02:18 AM

Jazz. The 2011/2012 Fiestas had the highest prevalence of DCT issues. Out of warranty, it'll cost you 60-80k to fix, and can still recur.

The Fiesta is a more rewarding drive but all that fun'll be sucked out of you if you get a faulty unit.

**Egan101** · March 5th, 2015 12:14 PM

The Fiesta is a better drive over the Jazz but its 2011/2012 models are the most common impacted by the tranny issues. There are still exceptions though, as stated by experiences of some members in FCP.

The Jazz offers a lot of space for a small car. The 1.5L models will offer better FC and power than the lower trim 1.3L models.Things I don't like about the City/Jazz are the boring feel of the steering and the "ka-blag" suspension feel on the rear.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

The Fiesta is a better drive over the Jazz but its 2011/2012 models are the most common impacted by the tranny issues. There are still exceptions though, as stated by experiences of some members in FCP.

The Jazz offers a lot of space for a small car. The 1.5L models will offer better FC and power than the lower trim 1.3L models.Things I don't like about the City/Jazz are the boring feel of the steering and the "ka-blag" suspension feel on the rear.

**1D4LV** · March 5th, 2015 12:37 PM

jazz..... higher resale value.

**niky** · March 5th, 2015 03:08 PM

The Fiesta drives better and is more refined, but the Jazz has, hands down, the better transmission. More responsive in traffic, not as jerky, and not a headache for long term ownership.

The Jazz also has a better ride. The Sport+ Fiesta is a bit stiff. The Jazz isn't going to entertain you as much, but it's still a nice steer and drives well... and the interior space is unbeatable for subcompacts of that vintage.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

The Fiesta drives better and is more refined, but the Jazz has, hands down, the better transmission. More responsive in traffic, not as jerky, and not a headache for long term ownership.

The Jazz also has a better ride. The Sport+ Fiesta is a bit stiff. The Jazz isn't going to entertain you as much, but it's still a nice steer and drives well... and the interior space is unbeatable for subcompacts of that vintage.