2016 Ranger Wildtrak 4X2 Manual VS. 2016 Hilux G 4X2 Automatic

[miguel20]

Its really hard for me to decide between these two pickup trucks priced at 1,365,000 and 1,283,000 respectively. Im in dire need of professional advices and comments and opinions of the owners of each vehicle.

Main points:

Reliabilty
Maintenance Costs
Overall performance
Fuel Consumption
Replacement parts cost and availability.

PS: Strictly limited to 2016 models.

Sent from my SM-N910C using Tsikot Forums mobile app

[Walter]

Get the Toyota Hilux, better reliability, cheaper to maintain, better parts availability ...

[babkalakal]

Hilux din ako particularly if this will serve as also your daily driver becase of AT convinience.

[vinj]

Based on the criteria, Hilux has an edge on maintenance, reliability and parts. The Ranger may have the edge in ride comfort.

[miguel20]

Based on the criteria, Hilux has an edge on maintenance, reliability and parts. The Ranger may have the edge in ride comfort.

Ali ba mas recommended? AT o MT? Hows the fuel economy of each?

Sent from my SM-N910C using Tsikot Forums mobile app

[miguel20]

Get the Toyota Hilux, better reliability, cheaper to maintain, better parts availability ...

Talaga bang significantly lesser in the long run ang maintenance o pms cost ng hilux compared to ranger?

Sent from my SM-N910C using Tsikot Forums mobile app

[miguel20]

Hilux din ako particularly if this will serve as also your daily driver becase of AT convinience.

Smooth din ba ang AT ng hilux? If compared sa MT, which would you recommend? Manual driver kasi ako eh but im open to driving matic naman

Sent from my SM-N910C using Tsikot Forums mobile app

[StockEngine]

Same parts availability-imo, with so many buyers of ford nowadays, some shops started carrying parts for the ranger and everest. The new fortuners and hilux are also new. I dont think all shops have parts for the new suvs/pickups. Hoping the shops carry the new parts for these new big sellers from ford and toyota.

Same reliability imo
Same fuel consumption if both mt/at

Only difference will be which transmission you want to get.

Automatic ka na lng for convenience, hirap traffi sa pinas hehehe.

[Lakwatsero]

Hilux if you value maintenance and reliability. Ford may have improved but personally wouldn't want one as a daily driver.

[Wishing]

Parang apple vs oranges. Choose automatic, be it a Ranger or Hilux kasi nga sobrang trapik. Pero kung Ranger ang type mo then get the manual kasi mas mataas resale value ng manual na ranger compared sa matic na ranger and mas madali mabenta ang manual na pickup compared sa matic lalo na sa province. Pero alam mo naman dito satin sa Pinas, always panalo ang Toyota brand name compared sa Ford. Pagdating sa after sales service both brand have good dealers like Ford Balintawak, Ford Commonwealth, Toyota Balintawak, Toyota North EDSA but never ever Toyota Commonwealth (super palpak). Pagdating sa performance, patas lang ang Ranger and Hilux, nasa brand preference mo lang talaga. Pareho din matibay (kung aalagaan) at marupok (kung lalaspagin at barubal). Pareho din lang range ng preventive maintenance, di yan magkakalayo. Pero, ngunit, subalit, datapwat, sa katagalan, (kung may balak ka patagalin ang ownership sa pickup mo, as in more than 10yrs kasi matibay naman talaga mga pickup) then sulit ka kung Toyota kasi mas mura ang mga pyesa. Pyesa meaning major parts like pangilalim (suspension), transmissions (clutch), engine (piston rings, overhaul gaskets, timing chain or belts), steering (pitman arm, ball joints). Kung i-dispose mo rin lang within 5years, parehas lang gastos mo sa maintenance kasi wala naman or napaka minimal na masiraan ka ng major part. Yung oil, oil filter, gulong, mags, parehas lang naman cost nyan be it Ford or Toyota.
Pag dating sa gadgets pareho din lang na madaming aftermarket parts like lift kits, chrome accents, etc. just to make truck more personalized.

To summarize, kung saan ka masaya, buhay at pera mo yan.

[rukawa11]

Mukhang Hilux sir ang pasok sa needs mo, pero kung looks ang hanap mo mag Ranger ka, dami ko nakikita Hilux na ginagawang security patrol at pang pickup ng mga construction worker


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[babkalakal]

Smooth din ba ang AT ng hilux? If compared sa MT, which would you recommend? Manual driver kasi ako eh but im open to driving matic naman

Sent from my SM-N910C using Tsikot Forums mobile app

Modern ATs are very good nowadays so I don't think magkakaproblem ka in that respect of smoothness or ever responsiveness. However may issue yun AT ng fortuner which yun unit ng mother ko is affected. It is now addressed naman by toyota to our satisfaction. I guess test drive ka muna ng hilux AT then you can make your decision. AT is nothing short of a godsend lalo na sa manila traffic nowadays.

[dr. d]

Ali ba mas recommended? AT o MT? Hows the fuel economy of each?

Sent from my SM-N910C using Tsikot Forums mobile app

the AT versus MT battle has reached mahabharatha proportions.
there is an entire thread dedicated to this topic alone.
peruse it, sir.
in the end, my conclusion is, "it is always a personal choice".
i have both AT and MT. and even then, the pros and cons do not paint a clear picture choice that covers all driving conditions. i usually pick one over the other, depending on the type of driving i am about to embark on.

fuel efficiency? on paper, MT trumps AT. but there are those who will dis-agree. we each have our own driving styles.

[Kingfrezes]

Talaga bang significantly lesser in the long run ang maintenance o pms cost ng hilux compared to ranger?

Sent from my SM-N910C using Tsikot Forums mobile app

We own one hilux 4x2 2.4 manual transmission nga lang..matipid naman siya sa maintinance at talagang reliable ginagamit pa nga namin yun pang karga ng parts ng heavy equipment