Mazda 3 hatchback or Honda Jazz???

[kathleentan]

http://www.canadiandriver.com/testdr...mazda3_3-1.jpg
MAZDA 3 HATCHBACK

http://img443.imageshack.us/img443/3923/jazztz8.jpg
HONDA JAZZ

[vinj]

You have to determine first factors that you consider/value such as:
- resale value? - honda has an edge
- performance? - Jazz 1.3 vs. Mazda3 1.6, Mazda 3 handles like a dream
- fuel economy? - Jazz no doubt
- space? - Jazz seems to have better space utilization but the Mazda is still a full-size sedan.
- city or highway driving? - both are quiote easy to drive (the JAzz has the advantage of size in the city), on long trips the Mazda may be better due to it's heft.

My .02

[ghosthunter]

What do you value more?

Riding comfort? Fuel economy? Resale value? Cargo capacity?

The Mazda3 HB rides better and has better seats than the Jazz. You'll know this very well if you drive longer distances. Mazda3 also handles better with nice feedback from the car. The Jazz's power steering feels disconnected from the road, kinda feels driving one of those racing video games.

The Jazz (as mentioned above) gets better fuel economy because of its engine and its lighter weight as well.

Honda gets better resale value BUT if you are buying your Mazda3 HB from the used car market, you might actually get a better deal (as compared to the Jazz).

Cargo capacity... its basically a hit and miss here. The Jazz can fit more stuff for a car of its size BUT the Mazda3 HB can still get more things inside simply because the Mazda3 is a bigger vehicle.

My personal choice... Mazda3 HB over the Jazz.

[niky]

Resale value... the Mazda3 may not have the "Honda" cachet, but resale value isn't actually bad.

The Mazda3 is a much better car, inside and out, except in terms of fuel economy and power... while the Jazz is kind of fun to drive, tama nga si gh, it's like driving a video game. The newer Jazzes have heavier steering but it's still kinda disconnected... the Mazda3, however, is pleasing to drive in all aspects (again, except for the lack of power).

[basti08]

i dont like non-independent rear suspension.

i vote for Mazda3 HB.

besides its more car for the money.

[oldblue]

feeling bmw naman mz3 hatch eh, mahal mahal liit naman

[mbeige]

double post...

[Mguy]

Cargo capacity... its basically a hit and miss here. The Jazz can fit more stuff for a car of its size BUT the Mazda3 HB can still get more things inside simply because the Mazda3 is a bigger vehicle.

Sorry but I beg to differ here. This is the very reason why I chose Jazz over the Mazda Hatch when I was shopping for a car.

The Jazz holds a way lot more than the Mazda Hatch. Even if the Mazda is a bigger car, the Jazz ULT seats and high roof line clearly is the winner here. Sure you could still put a lot of stuff inside the Mazda but not the big ones. I once had to load a 29" inch TV and a very big and long Caha de Oro with no problems at all.

The Mazda is a very good car, no mistake about it. Some find it a bit underpowered but I find it just ok for city driving. The seats are comfortable.

In spite of the steering feedback of the Jazz, it is still fun to drive, specially the CVT. Very economical and if you get the VTEC engine, very responsive.

IMO, you need to see the strengths of each car and see what you really need. Test drive both to get a real feel.

[redorange]

Surprisingly the Jazz can actually hold more cargo than the Mazda 3 hatchback even with it's size.

Specs
Mazda 3 hatchback w/ seats up 17.1 cubic feet w/ seats folded 31.2
passenger volume 95.4 cubic feet.

Honda Jazz w/ seats up 21.3 cubic feet w/ seats folded 41.9
passenger volume 90.0 cubic feet

If you feel that you will carry cargo more than people then the Jazz may be better along with it's fuel economy. But if you value passenger space more than cargo capacity along with driving feel then the Mazda 3 is the better vehicle.

[mbeige]

i dont like non-independent rear suspension.

i vote for Mazda3 HB.

besides its more car for the money.

The rear torsion beam axle of the Jazz is still independent, the center beam just twists (kaya siya tinatawag na torsion beam) to place each wheel properly on the ground. In addition it's also a trailing arm type of suspension.

Agreed, it's not performance based, but what it lacks in performance it can carry inside.

In spite of the steering feedback of the Jazz, it is still fun to drive, specially the CVT. Very economical and if you get the VTEC engine, very responsive.

What's wrong with the steering feedback of the Jazz? IMO (we have one) it's actually well weighted and very handy dahil maliit yung size ng steering wheel. Only complaint ko sa Jazz is when you run over a bump, matagtag masyado. The front MacPherson strut doesn't handle it well.

[Mguy]

What's wrong with the steering feedback of the Jazz? IMO (we have one) it's actually well weighted and very handy dahil maliit yung size ng steering wheel. Only complaint ko sa Jazz is when you run over a bump, matagtag masyado. The front MacPherson strut doesn't handle it well.

Well, at first, you get the feel that you're just playing Playstation with the feedback sort of feels 'synthetic'. But as you drive along, it really quite comfortable and responsive. Some people are just used to the heavier feedback of power steering when turning into a corner.

True, the suspension leaves much to be desired. Just last weekend, I had a trip to a rough road in Tagaytay and I felt the front suspension rattling. But when you drive in say EDSA or the highways, tahimik nya at very smooth.

[kathleentan]

So... What should i buy? I'm confused!

[redorange]

So... What should i buy? I'm confused!

Your going to have to test drive both cars to figure out which car you prefer. We can tell you all the pros and cons of each model but we won't be the one to purchase it and drive it daily so we can't tell you which one to buy. Do a test drive and get a feel of which car you like more.

[ryan]

To add to your confusion, how about the Toyota Yaris nalang. I think it looks cool as a lady driven car

[Tacoma_34]

how much is the mazda 3 hatch over there?

[ale828]

depends on your priorities in buying the car.
The jazz for its fuel economy, easy drivability, honda resale, its utility.
The mazda3 hatch if you carry more passengers, has better brakes, steering?, or your preference for larger cars.

[kyoots]

we're really comparing cars in two different categories - a subcompact car (jazz) and a compact car (mazda3) - which gives a lot of performance edge to the mazda3, and which is practically why the jazz has the edge on fuel economy and price.

i'd say it'd be best to check your budget - the mazda3 goes beyond the 850k bracket while the jazz costs a hundred thousand below it.

[beemdabolyo]

we cant compare the 2. they are in different categories. mazda3 HB is my choice, if we really have to compare the two.

[pdc2]

If you're just concerned with the fuel economy and price - go Jazz. Otherwise, no contest here - M3 is clearly the better one.

[Blackraven]

we're really comparing cars in two different categories - a subcompact car (jazz) and a compact car (mazda3) - which gives a lot of performance edge to the mazda3, and which is practically why the jazz has the edge on fuel economy and price.

i'd say it'd be best to check your budget - the mazda3 goes beyond the 850k bracket while the jazz costs a hundred thousand below it.

we cant compare the 2. they are in different categories. mazda3 HB is my choice, if we really have to compare the two.

I agree. The MZ3 HB is a "compact" while the Fit/Jazz is a "subcompact".

The two cannot directly be compared against each other.

What factors matter to you most? Vehicle price? More performance or better fuel economy? Vehicle size? Service & maintenance? Resale value?

What are you exactly looking for in a car?