Kia Carnival or Toyota Innova?

[imperialv]

Pwedeng manual close ang carnival.. Who said na takaw holdap ang carnival.. Actually iiwasan nga yan because of the power door.. For 4 years of ownership, never naman ako naholdup... Besides, kahit manual door yan, kapag gusto kang holdapin ng tao, gagawa ng paraan yan...

Heard good reviews sa carnival except one: prone sa holdap kasi super bagal magclose nung power side doors. Nakapasok na kawatan sa loob kotse d pa fully close. Tapos d daw pwede manual close. Can you confirm this carnival owners?


Sent from my iPhone4 using Tapatalk

[siopaonatoasted]

Pagdating sa parts, parehas lang availability nyan kung mahilig ka sa OEM, pero kung type eh mga replacements, mukhang dehado sa carnival.

Reliability wise, proven na ang german technology sa crdi, yung sa Toyota di pa proven.

Di pa ako nakasakay sa Kia Carnival, pero kung tatalunin nya ang legroom ng Innova at ang space na ang luwag, mas ok ang Carnival.

[bjreyesmd]

Hmm, reliability-wise, yung Kia Sedona/Carnival namin na year 2002 pa, no major problems so far sa engine. Ilang biyahe na rin sa Bicol region year in and year out.

[vinj]

Hmm, reliability-wise, yung Kia Sedona/Carnival namin na year 2002 pa, no major problems so far sa engine. Ilang biyahe na rin sa Bicol region year in and year out.

Nasa maintenance na rin talaga yan.

[IMm29]

Di pa ako nakasakay sa Kia Carnival, pero kung tatalunin nya ang legroom ng Innova at ang space na ang luwag, mas ok ang Carnival.

The Carnival is wider, so in terms of space, there's more shoulder room in the Carnival. Legroom is a given, especially in the 3rd row. I really like the LWB and how that 3rd row folds flat into the floor. That's perhaps something the Innova would have an advantage in -- stowing the 3rd row seats away in a jiffy for surprise loading.

[valskie01]

Pagdating sa parts, parehas lang availability nyan kung mahilig ka sa OEM, pero kung type eh mga replacements, mukhang dehado sa carnival.

Reliability wise, proven na ang german technology sa crdi, yung sa Toyota di pa proven.

Di pa ako nakasakay sa Kia Carnival, pero kung tatalunin nya ang legroom ng Innova at ang space na ang luwag, mas ok ang Carnival.

Talo ang innova sa carnival sa lahat ng room. Headroom, shoulder room and legroom


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk - now Free

[gentatski]

What is your analysis on this one guys? We're looking for a good family mpv...It seems these 2 are almost the same in terms of exterior look..mas manguso lng ata ng konti yung carnival..

1) passenger comfortability
2) which has a higher ground clearance? for better flood wading
3) fuel efficiency
4) handling
5) cheaper maintenance cost
6) spare parts cost and availability

go with innova

[Mr. Excitement]

Innova for me.

[EQAddict]

All new carnival for me base model has excellent value for money

Sent from my SM-N920I using Tapatalk

[CVT]

For 2016,-

If you have the dough,- go for the Carnival....


"The measure of a man is what he does with power" LJIOHF!

29.7K _/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/_/

[Wh1stl3r2]

Innova if you're going to drive it yourself, Carnival if you have a driver. The Carnival is so wide it's challenging to find a parking spot. Narrow slots and narrow spaced between parking rows are big no-no's. Imagine being just as long as a GS but much wider. The driver's view of the front is also limited, and ground clearance is pretty low. That with the long wheelbase makes tall speed bumps really annoying. But apart from that, the interior is no contest. Carnival is definitely much more upscale in interior appointments.

[ronw123w124]

Carnival for me especially after having driven one last week as our rental car in the US, loved the way it rode and handled although the one I drove is the gas V6 version. But i believe the the diesel version being sold here is no slouch either. Loved the US version Sedona/Carnival that I drove that it got me thinking about selling my Grand Starex.

The Innova is also a good choice, really depends on your needs.

[dct]

Innova if you're going to drive it yourself, Carnival if you have a driver. The Carnival is so wide it's challenging to find a parking spot. Narrow slots and narrow spaced between parking rows are big no-no's. Imagine being just as long as a GS but much wider. The driver's view of the front is also limited, and ground clearance is pretty low. That with the long wheelbase makes tall speed bumps really annoying. But apart from that, the interior is no contest. Carnival is definitely much more upscale in interior appointments.

Parang baliktad for me. Mas refined ang carnival kaya mas masarap idrive compared sa innova. So ibigay mo na sa driver ang innova at ikaw na lang sa carnival

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

[Wh1stl3r2]

Parang baliktad for me. Mas refined ang carnival kaya mas masarap idrive compared sa innova. So ibigay mo na sa driver ang innova at ikaw na lang sa carnival

Sent from my SM-N9005 using Tapatalk

Hirap na kasi magdala ng malaki sa city, siguro kung long drive on good roads I'd consider driving the Carnival. Sa singitan sa city nakakainis na magdala ng malaki, lalo na pag malapad. Kung Carnival ang sinasakyan mas gusto ko na sa 2nd row, masarap matulog

[glntVR]

Has the thread starter chosen a car already? Anyway, since it was resurrected, based on what
they look for in a car (Ground clearance, floor fording) Innova seems to be the obvious choice.
But if they want comfort and good size, they can also consider the new 8-seater Odyssey.

[Mel Vin]

The topic was 2013

[1D4LV]

depends on your need/wants. if it is a strictly a family vehicle, parang mas favorable ako sa Carnival. But if it doubles up as a hauler and at the same time, occassional family use during weekends and daily drives from home to work, Innova.

What is your analysis on this one guys? We're looking for a good family mpv...It seems these 2 are almost the same in terms of exterior look..mas manguso lng ata ng konti yung carnival..

1) passenger comfortability - Carnival
2) which has a higher ground clearance? for better flood wading - Innova
3) fuel efficiency - Innova
4) handling - Carnival
5) cheaper maintenance cost - Innova
6) spare parts cost and availability- Innova

[dr1v3r]

We own a carnival 2012 and still no problem hangang ngyn

Sent from my E6683 using Tsikot Forums mobile app

[ronw123w124]

We own a carnival 2012 and still no problem hangang ngyn

Sent from my E6683 using Tsikot Forums mobile app

How's the parts availability for the Carnival? Marami na rin ba outside of the casa?

[dr1v3r]

Regarding sa parts outside casa, actually wala kaming idea, since my parent's carnival is casa maintained since day 1. Wala pa naman parts na narereplace upto now

How's the parts availability for the Carnival? Marami na rin ba outside of the casa?

Sent from my E6683 using Tsikot Forums mobile app