hyundai i10 1.1 vs suzuki alto k10 (celerio engine inside an alto body)

[lance19]

good day car gurus...

for weeks now we are pondering what to have as our first baby, considering the traffic situation here in the philippines and economy wise, we narrowed our choices to two, the hyundai i10 and the suzuki alto k10... could you please impart some knowledge on what to choose between the said cars... what we need to know;

1. FUEL EFFICIENCY - i10 claims 20.4 kpl while k10 is 20.2
2. HANDLING - i10 has motor powered EPS while k10 has EPS
3. MAINTENANCE - cheaper spare parts

thank you for your time... we need to come up with a decision before march 31' 12.... thanks!!!

[niky]

I haven't tested the manual i10, so I can't say whether it can do that on the highway... the automatic isn't great on the highway, but it's economical on low-speed long runs. The Alto 800cc was amazingly good in city traffic. The Celerio with the 1.0 engine can easily exceed 20 km/l... the Alto should be able to, also.

The i10 is, however, a much better car in every way except perhaps performance. The Alto is possibly more economical and feels more alive and more connected to the driver... but it can't match the i10's build quality.

[lance19]

I haven't tested the manual i10, so I can't say whether it can do that on the highway... the automatic isn't great on the highway, but it's economical on low-speed long runs. The Alto 800cc was amazingly good in city traffic. The Celerio with the 1.0 engine can easily exceed 20 km/l... the Alto should be able to, also.

The i10 is, however, a much better car in every way except perhaps performance. The Alto is possibly more economical and feels more alive and more connected to the driver... but it can't match the i10's build quality.

Sir nilky, when you say build quality, does that mean that the alto is more prone to wear and tear???? and sir the alto K10 engine is the same as the engine inside a celerio... they are now both 1L...

[renzo_d10]

IDK but mas madating yung i10. And niky was right, having seen a model unit sa GH maganda yung build ng i10 inside out. Yung plastics niya sa loob, ok naman. Doesn't feel cheap.

Haven't seen the interior of the K10 Alto eh. Pero basing from its looks outside, it's one good car. And mating it with a 1.0L engine pa, I'm sure it will bring you impressive fuel economy.

[niky]

Sir nilky, when you say build quality, does that mean that the alto is more prone to wear and tear???? and sir the alto K10 engine is the same as the engine inside a celerio... they are now both 1L...

Not really. What I mean is that the Alto feels cheaper made. Cheaper materials and stuff. But the mechanicals seem very good.

And yes, I know the Alto has the Celerio engine now. But since I haven't tested it yet, I can't relate the economy. I have driven the 800cc and was very impressed. I'm driving the K10 later this month.

[toyotaparter]

I had an i10 once as a company issued vehicle. easily did 18km/liter on the highway.

at first i, i was disappointed when i got it. because the other guys got the vios. But by the end, when they offered me a swap, hindi na ako pumayag. madali ipark, matipid sa gas, responsive engine. handles great too.

[drich_enriquez]

I had an i10 once as a company issued vehicle. easily did 18km/liter on the highway.

at first i, i was disappointed when i got it. because the other guys got the vios. But by the end, when they offered me a swap, hindi na ako pumayag. madali ipark, matipid sa gas, responsive engine. handles great too.

Correct me if I'm wrong sir di ba mas mura alto K10 kaysa sa i10? Both car are good especially first timers na budget wise drivers.

"Honey, did you find the remote?"- WWF's (now WWE) Val Venis with Mrs. Yamaguchi-san in a bed. Raw is War Aug. 1998.

[lance19]

Not really. What I mean is that the Alto feels cheaper made. Cheaper materials and stuff. But the mechanicals seem very good.

And yes, I know the Alto has the Celerio engine now. But since I haven't tested it yet, I can't relate the economy. I have driven the 800cc and was very impressed. I'm driving the K10 later this month.

sir niky, i'll be waiting for your review for the K10... hope it's M/T... ahehehe...