2008 grandis vs IMV fortuner 2.7 gas

[triggerman222]

Good day to all,
need help
Alam ko medyo di dapat sila icompare but i need the 7 seats.
what would you recommend in terms of :

- everyday use (weekdays 2 person)(weekends 6-7 person)
- long drive 3 hours minimum (at least once a month)
- fuel consumption
- ease of maintenance

thanks and more power

[number001]

In terms of third row legroom, the Fortuner is bit roomier because there is floor space unlike in the Grandis where the sitting position is closer to a crouch. But the Fortuner has a reputation for being bumpy (which I wouldn't know bec. I always sit infront).

[Memphis Raines]

I'd go for the Grandis hands down



The Fort has become too common for me. So common it has lost its appeal. The Grandis' design is waaaay ahead of its time.

my :twocents:

.

[yapoy86]

although wala sa choices.. why don't you take a look for a Kia Carnival LWB since you are looking for an everyday ride and at the same time a people mover...

3 hours drive will be exhausting so you need a comfortable ride... seats 7 comfortably yet still have space for some cargo. power sliding doors and tailgate pa..

[staind]

my cousin had a grandis which he was so glad to have sold. ang ganda kaso lakas daw sa gas!! swerte na raw 5km/liter.

[Gerbo]

i need the 7 seats.

Functionally, you can make do with either vehicle.

For me, i kind of view the Grandis as a glorified Innova but a cheaper alternative to the Previa. Driving mechanics would probably be in its favor.....good for long drives.

However, the Fortuner affords more versatility being an SUV. And being more popular, it has many units on the road.....meaning, parts availability and maintenance bits may not be harder to source.

It boils down, really, to what vehicle type you favor driving. Image-conscious ka ba?....as MPVs tend to portray "family man" or "soccer mom" feel compare to SUVs that portray sporty or a more masculine appeal.

If you chose the former, you would like also consider the Carnival (it comes in diesel and have better fuel economy plus a more torquey engine).

But personally, I will chose the Fortuner---better value for the money. Whatever negative things they would say---it remains a bestseller for its segment. And there are myriad of reasons for it.

In two words, "best value".

[Xt7]

my cousin had a grandis which he was so glad to have sold. ang ganda kaso lakas daw sa gas!! swerte na raw 5km/liter.

hala! 5km/liter?? tingin ko mag fortuner ka na lang. bukod sa mas malakas sa hatak, sa height, wala kang pangamba di gaya ng grandis na parang pina lowered na innova o previa ang dating (just for me). kahit 6-7 kayo tapos full loaded pa with your cargo and bags, mataas pa rin ang height. tapos sa FC, sa pinsan ko kc 2.7 vvti din nasa 7-8km/liter pa.. ang laking tipid dba..

kung sa grandis swerte mo naka 5km/liter (sabi nung isa), sa fortuner ng pinsan ko swerte mo maka 8-9km/liter sa 2.7vvti.. ok na rin diba...

[Horsepower]

The BEST car for your purpose is the Hyundai Santa Fe 2.2L CRDi.

It's a monocoque space frame body 7-seater which makes it so comfortable even for a single passenger. Even fully loaded with seven people, you can still hit 200kmh. Hwy economy is around 15-20km/L (i personally did 21). City is around 8-12 with occassional high speed sprints (it's hard to resist). Angelic driving can give around 15-16km/L in the city (and if you purposely avoid traffic).

It's only a million and a half.

If you don't like Hyundai (World's fifth best selling automaker), then you can buy Mitsubishi Montero Sport.

If you are going to sell this car within two years, then get Fortuner as we still don't know the resale of the two (owners rarely dispose of theirs).


Good luck ^_^

[Burai]

are you really gonna limit your picks for those 2 only? dami kasi na 7seater na mas maganda eh. pero if that's the case then
hmm..
for uniqueness, go for grandis
di ko lam FC niya. lowerd and looks underpowered. good looking. nice in and out

for many purposes, i'd go for fortuner
malaki good for baha. 8km+/l is nice for a big car. 3rd row's nice. pwede ifold 3rd row . bulky. off road ready. hindi na head turner sa dami sa kalsada which is good para iwas magnanakaw. roomy. nice ride height. tapos kung yung latest na fortuner edi maganda pwesto ng mga aircon vents niya. bad side lang is ikaw magpapalit suspension pero so far overall id chose this one over grandis

for alternatives, there's always the carens and sta fe when you want to save some money but still offers a good 7 seating arrangement. sportivo? XD

[cta2]

was also choosing between the 2...

I ended up with a second hand Grandis!... This car has many surprises, very refined... as in mid size car refinement!... space is abundant for 1 and 2nd row... 3rd row will have space if 2nd row will share legroom (just like fortuner)... quite fast too, it can outdrive a Fortuner / Trooper easily... speed and handling!

I got it coz it cheaper than a fortuner (2nd hand or brand new)... the only issues I have for the Grandis is resale (which doesnt matter to me, esp i got it 2nd hand)... Gas consumption is 6Km... on the high side, but tolerable on my end. My other car also does 6Kms

Driving a Van alone or as a couple, might feel weird... it is still a van... mukhang Daddy talaga (can be a pro or con... up to you)


Bottom line with my own money and if I drive...
Brand new: Fortuner (will do the job, higher resale, will not be weird driving alone)
2nd Hand: Grandis hands down!

But if I have a driver: Grandis brand new!

just my 2 cents

[badbadtz.carlo]

was also choosing between the 2...

I ended up with a second hand Grandis!... This car has many surprises, very refined... as in mid size car refinement!... space is abundant for 1 and 2nd row... 3rd row will have space if 2nd row will share legroom (just like fortuner)... quite fast too, it can outdrive a Fortuner / Trooper easily... speed and handling!

I got it coz it cheaper than a fortuner (2nd hand or brand new)... the only issues I have for the Grandis is resale (which doesnt matter to me, esp i got it 2nd hand)... Gas consumption is 6Km... on the high side, but tolerable on my end. My other car also does 6Kms

Driving a Van alone or as a couple, might feel weird... it is still a van... mukhang Daddy talaga (can be a pro or con... up to you)


Bottom line with my own money and if I drive...
Brand new: Fortuner (will do the job, higher resale, will not be weird driving alone)
2nd Hand: Grandis hands down!

But if I have a driver: Grandis brand new!

just my 2 cents

i agree, driving this baby by yourself can feel freaky.. got to drive it to the airport when I had to pick up some relatives. It's so spacious and when you look in the rear view mirror.. parang may mga nakaupo sa likod.. hehehehe...

or maybe it's just me.. brand new pa kasi nun, kaya weird talaga..
pero when driving full.. mabilis pa ren cia and handles very well.. My tito who owns this say, he still hits 6-7 km/l which is not that bad.

I have yet to drive a Fort, hence I couldn't compare, but just for looks, handling and rarity of the Grandis compared to Fort, Grandis pa ren ako.

[cta2]

just want to add... the Grandis is NOT hard to drive... it just feels awkward driving alone....

easier to maneuver than a mid size SUV (pajero/fort/trooper... which i have compared)... turning radius is like a car, not a truck

its length and width is smaller than a Camry... shorter than a Ford everest

but if image is important plus resale... will still get a mid size SUV

Brand new Grandis is 1.250M, Fort will set you back 1.380M.... personally, its a hard choice!

[SaberRider]

The BEST car for your purpose is the Hyundai Santa Fe 2.2L CRDi.

It's a monocoque space frame body 7-seater which makes it so comfortable even for a single passenger. Even fully loaded with seven people, you can still hit 200kmh. Hwy economy is around 15-20km/L (i personally did 21). City is around 8-12 with occassional high speed sprints (it's hard to resist). Angelic driving can give around 15-16km/L in the city (and if you purposely avoid traffic).

It's only a million and a half.

If you don't like Hyundai (World's fifth best selling automaker), then you can buy Mitsubishi Montero Sport.

If you are going to sell this car within two years, then get Fortuner as we still don't know the resale of the two (owners rarely dispose of theirs).


Good luck ^_^

I haven't seen a Hyundai Santa Fe kick 200kph... not even in Youtube. Besides, the Manufacturers claim is just 180kph(no electronic limitations here) but I know it can hit 186kph. Fellow Santa Fe owner myself.

Nwei, Grandis or Fortuner. Minivan or SUV?
Ride height - Fortuner
Interior Space - Fortuner
Interior looks - Grandis
fuel efficiency - none
parts available(maski sa banawe) - fortuner
exterior looks - Grandis, eyesore na fortuner specially the ones with all the chrome kits.
resale value - for now, fortuner

Magandang match-up is Grandis vs. Grand Starex - Starex wins hands down by overall packaging!
Fortuner vs. Santa Fe - meadyo malapit na laban ito!

[Horsepower]

you just need an open road (NLEX, SCTEX and STAR) although sometimes, traffic. A lot of SFs have already reached 200, some even surpassed it. ^_^

[Burai]

just adding something from my previous post above (kahit medyo OT), maganda rin naman mga katulad ng grandis lalo na yung subaru exiga. i dunno lang kung kasing exciting and fun to drive (as what subaru.jp said) niya ang exiga. if it is not hard to drive, then its fun to drive

teka
is it like parang nagddrive ka alone using a grand livina ba? hehehe

[eggman]

Maganda ang Grandis at mura nalang ngayon sya....A must buy dahil eto ang isa sa underrated MPV ng Pinas..

[rossph]

We have both cars. Although our Fortuner is the 3.0V. I would highly recommend the Grandis if you have little kids. When we travel I have 2 little kids (Age 3 and 1.5 with their car seats) and 2 yayas and of course my wife. I feel the Grandis is the most underrated MPV out there. Feels and rides like a midsize sedan but not the midsize sedan price. I agree that it is very refined. It's a much cheaper alternative to the Toyota Previa. Our Fortuner really feels like a truck after you ride the Grandis. From time to time we also use it for going to the office. For me the only downsides are the low ground clearance and the fuel economy. Average fuel economy for me is 6.5-7.5kpl mixed city and highway.