I'm helping a friend out.. these are the 2 options. Are these units price reasonably?

a. 2000 Starex SVX
Manual
116t mileage
newly overhauled
Faded Paint but tolerable

Php 360T


b. 2007 Innova G - Diesel
Matic
27t mileage
Makinis at Sariwa inside and out
Php 680T


It's not fair po to compare the two because of it's age and price, pero ito ang choices nya. Questions nya includes..

Reliability... since the starex was overhauled against D4D woes..
Fuel Consumption... sino mas matipid since manual vs matic
Comfort...

Resale Value doesn't matter.


Thanks