Empathy for Traffic Enforcers.

[eojlin]

Creating this thread as an OT response to a message from another thread:

* On stricter implementation of traffic laws by traffic enforcers.

This is actually very ideal and is very much needed. But realistically, implementing this 24/7 is close to impossible. (Kaya dapat sa licensing or LTO meron ng tunay na control.)

Why did i say close to impossible?

(Before anything else, I am a not cop or a traffic enforcer. I enjoy my desk job in an air-conditioned room or office like most us here.)
1. Yung init sa labas ng mga kalsada natin ay hindi tolerable. Kahit ako, di ko na-i-imagine na tatayo ako sa labas ng init ng araw para magbantay sa mahabang oras na lumilipas. Though, they've been provided with roofed stations na sinlaki ng dog house ng kapitbahay ko, ma-i-inspire ka ba magtrabaho. Siguro kung nasa countries ka with cooler climates and equipped with muscle cars or big bikes, hahabol ka talaga sa mga offenders. So try not to compare our situation here in the Philippines with others.
2. Sa liit ng wages or salaries nila, i-b-bully pa sila ng mga ina-a-apprehend nila - kesyo anak ni councilor, ni mayor, ni congressman, or ni biz tycoon kaya waived lahat ng huli, or kesyo mas malaki katawan, mas malakas boses, mas maton, at mas mautak ka pa sa enforcers.
3. They have to deal with graft and corruption every single moment while doing their job (not talking about "buwaya" na hiyang na sa bribery). Konting corruption or bureaucracy sa office naaasar tayo. Paano pa kaya sila na oras-oras merong gustong mag-bribe.
4. If traffic enforcers find it NOT easy apprehending cars, how about apprehending imperceptible and elusive bikes.
5. Ratio of enforcers to road intersections and vehicles. Kulang sila.
6. I bet, most of them (not all) if they could only trade jobs or careers with you (or us) they would in a heartbeat.

The most they can do is signal us where to drive or when to go and stop.

I am not saying that they should lax on their jobs. Neither do I imply to NOT depend on them. Realistically, (other than LTO control) it is up to us (drivers - bikers or not) to be responsible on the road. Wag tayo masyado umasa sa kanila, dahil parang umasa na rin tayo sa himala.

Motorcycle or car drivers, let's all do our part. Specially bikes since you're more difficult to apprehend and your number is immensely growing.

[morrissey_05]

i feel ya man. ma-empathy yata ako na tao. that's why i make it a policy to treat them the way they treat me. i start try to talk in a respectful tone. pero kung bastusan na, bastusan na rin.

[Lucius]

Kung iisipin, kawawa din sila. Imagine being under the sun everyday? Talo pa nila bagong tint na auto. Kya ok din maglagay minsan, pamerienda lang. Ung sa EDSA nga nakakaawa parang di nilalaban uniform hehehe.

[eojlin]

Hehe... kahit bagong extra uniform yata, nagdadalawang isip pa sila kung bibili o hindi. Ilan ba standard issue sa kanila? Ano kaya kung mag-pulis ako, ano kaya rank ko, simula ba ko sa pinaka-mababa?

[redorange]

Kung iisipin, kawawa din sila. Imagine being under the sun everyday? Talo pa nila bagong tint na auto. Kya ok din maglagay minsan, pamerienda lang. Ung sa EDSA nga nakakaawa parang di nilalaban uniform hehehe.

So where do you draw the line between a bribe and a donation? Are you still willing to get the traffic citation after you give them money? If your answer is "no" then you are just giving them a bribe and trying to justify your actions. Regardless of what their work conditions are they picked their job and they knew that they would be exposed to the hot sun everyday. No type of rationalization can justify giving money to a law enforcement officer, because they are not supposed to accept money from the public that they serve lest it be seen as a bribe. If you really feel sorry for them then talk to your government officials to have these people paid more and thus less likely to accept bribes.

[Marc MD]

actually there is a certain amount that they get for every citation made or ticket issued.. kind of like a commission.. but i think the amount is still not enough.. maybe if they had salary like those from the call centers.. but that's another story medyo mahirap yata ma-achieve yun..

[aldrizz]

sorry mga guys ha, eto opinion ko lang...

i really cant feel empathy for these lalo yung capable of issuing tickets. sakin kc, d naman sa nilalahat ko pero kc masmadalas ang mga malokong enforcers than the good ones. i appreciate the good ones very much pero in reality i still have to meet one. sa 8 times na naflag down ako for the 4 years na nandito ako sa luzon n got to drive by the metro, lahat mga kurakot talga. nakaka asar. 3 of times, they flagged me down for a violation d ko ginawa... un ang pinaka paborito nila... swerving! i was changing lanes kc bottleneck nawawala na ung lane ko... aba swerving daw! n the same goes when i was going to turn at the intersection, so i had to change to the outer lane... wla ako inalangan (cut) na car sa likod, aba e swerving pa rin? sa 8 na un, 4 was really blatantly stupid calls. the 2 of them was sadya ko kc i drove kahit coding ako. the other 3 was because i was unfamiliar with the places and i made bad judgments.

what i am trying to say is, i cant feel empathy for them because all the enforcers that flagged me down were all bad apples, giving hassles to a responsible motorist. most of the enforcers pa that flagged me was overcharging and taking advantage... ako kc taga laguna, d ko maaasikaso pag nahuli ako sa metro so i tend to bribe nalng kung ppwede. when they sense this... kagat sila agad and they charge me more than what i will actually pay (i found it out nung i asked about the charges for the violations). kabadtrip tlaga.

i obey traffic rules, but when there are times that there are unclear signs or even no signs at all (pero meron at ang nakakaalam lang ay mga taga dun at madalas dun) sana man lang magbigay sila ng warning. d mo maiiwasan talga na matanga ka pag d mo alam ung lugar e, lalo dito satin wlang proper signages sana man lang if ung driver is deserving naman of a warning, ibigay nila... pero mas una nila naiisip kc perahan muna ung driver e.

n besides, bakit kapag busses trucks jeeps taxis and MC's d naman nila hinuhuli? most of the time nagbubulagbulagan lang sila kahit harap harapan na ang violation? i can only think of one reason, kc most of them d nagbibigay ng lagay dahil walang pera. kaya mga private ang laging tinitira sa traffic violations.

i cant help but compare our enforcers sa province against dito sa metro. sa amin i can empathize in a heartbeat... pero dito, i really cant. this is because sa province namin, ang mga enforcers always make good calls and they concentrate more on keeping the streets organized by flagging down lokong PUV's and trucks.

[Marc MD]

Creating this thread as an OT response to a message from another thread:

* On stricter implementation of traffic laws by traffic enforcers.

This is actually very ideal and is very much needed. But realistically, implementing this 24/7 is close to impossible. (Kaya dapat sa licensing or LTO meron ng tunay na control.)

Why did i say close to impossible?

(Before anything else, I am a not cop or a traffic enforcer. I enjoy my desk job in an air-conditioned room or office like most us here.)
1. Yung init sa labas ng mga kalsada natin ay hindi tolerable. Kahit ako, di ko na-i-imagine na tatayo ako sa labas ng init ng araw para magbantay sa mahabang oras na lumilipas. Though, they've been provided with roofed stations na sinlaki ng dog house ng kapitbahay ko, ma-i-inspire ka ba magtrabaho. Siguro kung nasa countries ka with cooler climates and equipped with muscle cars or big bikes, hahabol ka talaga sa mga offenders. So try not to compare our situation here in the Philippines with others.
2. Sa liit ng wages or salaries nila, i-b-bully pa sila ng mga ina-a-apprehend nila - kesyo anak ni councilor, ni mayor, ni congressman, or ni biz tycoon kaya waived lahat ng huli, or kesyo mas malaki katawan, mas malakas boses, mas maton, at mas mautak ka pa sa enforcers.
3. They have to deal with graft and corruption every single moment while doing their job (not talking about "buwaya" na hiyang na sa bribery). Konting corruption or bureaucracy sa office naaasar tayo. Paano pa kaya sila na oras-oras merong gustong mag-bribe.
4. If traffic enforcers find it NOT easy apprehending cars, how about apprehending imperceptible and elusive bikes.
5. Ratio of enforcers to road intersections and vehicles. Kulang sila.
6. I bet, most of them (not all) if they could only trade jobs or careers with you (or us) they would in a heartbeat.

The most they can do is signal us where to drive or when to go and stop.

I am not saying that they should lax on their jobs. Neither do I imply to NOT depend on them. Realistically, (other than LTO control) it is up to us (drivers - bikers or not) to be responsible on the road. Wag tayo masyado umasa sa kanila, dahil parang umasa na rin tayo sa himala.

Motorcycle or car drivers, let's all do our part. Specially bikes since you're more difficult to apprehend and your number is immensely growing.

If you're trying to question my thought in the other thread, know this.. My brother is a Police Officer, mga kababata ko dito sa Makati became MAPSA.. nun May 1 lang kainuman pa namin dito sa Fiesta ang isang battalion ng MAPSA.. alam ko nararamdaman nila.. i know the heat in the Metro (in Fact yun isang MAPSA friend ko is mas maputi pa sa akin dati, ngayon halos kakulay nya na si Blakdyak ).. alam ko din ang tungkol sa mga padrino na yan.. i also know as a fact na for some reason e tumatanggap sila ng lagay (P50 minimum).. i have nothing against the enforcers in the Ph.. i'm just saying na do it properly.. it would be okay na pagbigyan yun iba once in a while (Filipinos after all are known for their pakikisama).. and in reality hindi naman talaga kaya hulihin lahat e..

But look at the Traffic Enforcers sa Fort? or sa Subic? sa Makati Parking lang e (yun sa Ayala CBD area).. mahigpit sila.. and most motorists there are maingat kasi tutuluyan talaga sila (ticket, tow or plate confiscation).. pero try mo pumunta sa Pasay and see for yourself (I would suggest yun intersection ng LRT and Buendia) sa harapan na mismo ng Enforcers (MMDA and BROWNBOYS) you'll see MC's passing in front of them (wala pa helmet) kahit stop pa and they don't mind (under the LRT yun so malilim at hindi gaano mainit).. minsan nanghuhuli sila pero most of the time pinababayaan lang nila mga MC's (like i said in the other thread baka nga naisip nila na sayang lang ng oras.. sa Pasay kasi pag taga Pasay ka and Brownboy nakahuli sayo pagbibigyan ka lang.. "katwiran is taga dito lang pala e"..

i remembered tuloy yun palabas sa TV.. "Pinoy Ikaw ba 'to?" by the Yakult Guy.. they did an experiment.. 2 girls on different cars will make the same traffic violation on the same street and with the same officer on the same day (syempre hidden cam ito and di alam ng officer). the catch is: one girl is maganda and the other is let's say.. less beautiful .. so they went through, both got flagged and guess what? OO! the maganda girl got off 100% through pakiusap lang while the other less fortunate girl got tickets at 8:10 ratio.. wala lang share ko lang.. hehe

i'll agree with you na what all of us need is discipline and knowledge on traffic rules and regulations.. i myself drive defensively.. i'd stop on a red light kahit 3a.m. at wala naman other cars..

as i was saying in the other thread hindi lahat ng officers ay ganun meron din naman na maayos trumabaho. pero not all.. there are good apples and bad apples talaga.. mapa-cager, MC, enforcer pati nga pedestrians e..



O.T. : kung gusto mo mag Pulis tutulungan ka namin hehe.. or you can apply for yourself sa NCRTS sa Camp Bagong Diwa, Taguig. Have to be College Graduate (kahit hindi Criminology.. yun iba nga Agriculture ang course e.. kung Law ka or Medical mas maganda opportunities mas maganda ranking). Curriculum is 6 months training. Classroom and Field Training. Jogging every morning and bago matulog. Hindi puwede umuwi (yes.. 6 months sa Barracks walang labasan)

Yes.. Start ka sa pinakamababa "PO1". Starting Salary is disclosed (di ko alam e ) pero may issue ka naman na brand new 9mm. with License (Nice)..

Uniforms and Patches are to be shouldered by themselves.. mahal ang isang set.. kaya you'll notice most officers having faded uniforms..

[Marc MD]

BTW sa Ayala Ave. pa lang ako nakakita ng BUS na sumusunod sa Loading only and Unloading only sections.. nakakatuwa kasi sumusunod ang mga bus drivers at kunduktor.. hindi talaga sila magsasakay sa Unloading only at hindi din sila magbababa sa loading only.. aawayin ka pa nila pag nagpumilit ka bumaba or sumakay sa di dapat.. nakakatuwa diba? in this way nga pedestrians are also disciplined kahit na yun office mo e nasa Ayala Ave mismo pero malayo ka sa loading area you'll have to walk pa to get there kahit malayo para lang sumakay. strict implementation, the result is disciplined drivers and pedestrians.. organized ang lahat..

i think naman sa umpisa lang mahirap ipatupad kasi madami talagang uneducated sa rules at mga likas na pasaway but once they experience the pangil of the law na strictly implemented e susunod din sila..

kaya sa kanilang lahat.. Bow Ako

[SNAKE V6]

Alam ko sa Marikina marami ng nahuling walang helmet, hahabulin ka nila hanggang makarating kas sa Antipolo boundary, hehehe..yun ang dapat.

[chua_riwap]

BTW sa Ayala Ave. pa lang ako nakakita ng BUS na sumusunod sa Loading only and Unloading only sections.. nakakatuwa kasi sumusunod ang mga bus drivers at kunduktor.. hindi talaga sila magsasakay sa Unloading only at hindi din sila magbababa sa loading only.. aawayin ka pa nila pag nagpumilit ka bumaba or sumakay sa di dapat.. nakakatuwa diba? in this way nga pedestrians are also disciplined kahit na yun office mo e nasa Ayala Ave mismo pero malayo ka sa loading area you'll have to walk pa to get there kahit malayo para lang sumakay. strict implementation, the result is disciplined drivers and pedestrians.. organized ang lahat..

i think naman sa umpisa lang mahirap ipatupad kasi madami talagang uneducated sa rules at mga likas na pasaway but once they experience the pangil of the law na strictly implemented e susunod din sila..

kaya sa kanilang lahat.. Bow Ako

Yun nga eh.....kung pwede sa Ayala Ave. (or Makati CBD), bakit di na lang i-implement Metro wide? Strict implementation ng rules at discipline ng tao lang talaga kailangan.

[j_avonni]

Yun nga eh.....kung pwede sa Ayala Ave. (or Makati CBD), bakit di na lang i-implement Metro wide? Strict implementation ng rules at discipline ng tao lang talaga kailangan.

Pero minsan may mga pasaway talaga. By and large, maganda ang loading / unloading scheme dyan sa Ayala Makati. It now depends if they could sustain the proper and strict implementation.

[Marc MD]

Yun nga eh.....kung pwede sa Ayala Ave. (or Makati CBD), bakit di na lang i-implement Metro wide? Strict implementation ng rules at discipline ng tao lang talaga kailangan.

Exactly! it just proves that it can be done.. prolonging it like that may not be a hard task for enforcers lalo na ngayon na takot na talaga mga motorists to violate.. it has been like that na ba for ilan years na din? i believe matagal na din..

[eojlin]

If you're trying to question my thought in the other thread, know this.. My brother is a Police Officer, mga kababata ko dito sa Makati became MAPSA...

But look at the Traffic Enforcers sa Fort? or sa Subic? sa Makati Parking lang e (yun sa Ayala CBD area)...
...

Actually yes, this thread is a response to your message in another thread (para lang di lumayo at masyadong OT na dun kaya ako gumawa ng separate thread). Plus, in a lot of other threads here at tsikot where some rely or blame traffic enforcers for being lenient. Subukan natin sabihin sa isang traffic enforcer ang mga katangang "Do it properly" ay baka bigla na lang syang mapa-iyak sa kawalan natin ng empathy o kaya naman bigla syang magalit at batukan ka.

But the greater goal or purpose of this thread is for others to know that the lives of traffic enforcers are not easy, and that we shouldn't rely so much on them to discipline all traffic violators - doing so is close to impossible. We can't blame them if we don't see them apprehending violators all the time. Some resolutions could be: more traffic enforcers, better equipment, better policies, "OR" higher wages - consequently requires more tax money to maintain OR non-corrupt city officials. But which cities can afford to maintain this - maintain for a long time.

Pero tama ka, iba talaga yung enforcement ng batas sa Makati, Fort, and Subic. Siguro kung makakapili lang yung mga enforcers natin, marami sa kanila nagpa-assign sa Subic.

Subic and Fort are different cases: They have their own traffic enforcers which definitely have different circumstances as with other local traffic enforcers. Obvious naman na different, i need not cite any - or maybe sa density of jurisdiction, policies, wage, and benefits.
Also, I agree, Makati's MAPSA is somehow better. They are the ones who probably get substantial amount of money for every ticket they issue.

So I guess, hindi yung local traffic enforcers sa mga kalsada ang dapat sinisisi (well, not in all cases).

Sabihin mo na lang sa MAPSA tropa mo na sikat naman si blakdyak at uso yung maitim ngayon.

OT: Ang hirap pala kung mag-s-shift ako ngayon ng career into pulis - one less pulis wannabe.

[Marc MD]

ang alam ko hindi lang MAPSA ang may commission basis sa ticketing system.. pati PNP and MMDA din..

Bayani Fernando did well in Marikina too diba? yun pinagdadala nya ng Itak yun mga enforcers instead of Batuta? o diba sumunod din mga makukulit na jeep sa kanila? Astig nga e.. kahit maliit budget makakagawa pa rin ng paraan para mapasunod mga motorists and pedestrians..

sa Pasay.. maybe lately mapapansin nyo may mga headset na EACH ang mga Brownboys.. i believe Radio yun for communication.. magkano isang radio? so ibig sabihin they have the budget for their people to use.. pero i don't know mukhang maliit pa din salary nila to be able to refuse bribe..

sa Fort mga security guards lang yun mga yun.. pero matatapang sila at may dangal and of course proud sila kasi kahit security guards lang sila e allowed sila to issue tickets.. they have their own O.V.R. kaya talagang tutuluyan ka nila to prove themselves worthy of the task and responsibility they've been given..

so kung pwede gawin locally, why not all the cities around follow suit? that way hindi din mabigat para sa PNP.. hindi ko din naman sinasabing i-asa lahat sa kanila.. sabi ko nga di naman nila kaya hulihin lahat e.. pero dapat kung sino man ang mahuli nila regardless of stature basta may violation talaga at wala naman valid or reasonable excuse e dapat nilang ticketan (or tow).. kung iipunin naman nila yun commission nila sa dami ng ma-issue nila sa isang araw e siguradong pwede na din pandagdag sa pang araw-araw e..

ito'ng nakakalungkot .. let's say inayos nga nila trabaho nila.. huli kung huli basta mali walang kinikilingan maging sino ka man (Naks!).. syempre mababawasan ang violators or if ever e sobrang minimized (maganda nga ).. pero syempre ultimately yun commission nila from ticketing e crippled din.. and they'll be left again with what? yun basic salary nila na hindi nga sufficient sa needs ng pamilya nila.. so pano na? balik ulit sa dati hulidap kotong.. and this awfully true scenario again suggests a need for salary increase for these enforcers which is AGAIN next to impossible due to widespread corruption from the government and massive Tax evasions from the public and private sectors..

whoo grabe ang layo ko na.. is this what they call a vicious cycle?
actually mahaba pa istorya nyan kaso siguradong O.T. na