OUST DE VENECIA CAMPAIGN
134 sign ‘no confidence’ paper vs Speaker--Villafuerte
To seek House leader’s voluntary resignation
By Maila Ager
INQUIRER.net
First Posted 15:01:00 01/31/2008
MANILA, Philippines -- (UPDATE) At least 134 lawmakers at the House of Representatives have signed a manifesto declaring “loss of confidence” in Speaker Jose de Venecia Jr., Kabalikat ng Malayang Pilipino (Partner of the Free Filipino, Kampi) president and Camarines Sur Representative Luis Villafuerte said Thursday.
Villafuerte said he would present the manifesto, signed by all 56 members of Kampi, 11 neophyte solons, and some members of the Liberal Party and De Venecia’s own party, the Lakas-Christian Muslim Democrats (CMD), to the Speaker on Monday and then ask him to voluntarily step down.
However, Majority Floor Leader Arthur Defensor of Iloilo laughed off Villafuerte’s disclosure and challenged the Kampi president to bring the matter to the floor for a vote.
“Sa sabi lang ni Villafuerte maniniwala na kami sa kanya? Hintayin na lang natin kung may tao nga. Pakita niya muna sa [Just because Villafuerte says so, we should believe hium? Let’s wait until there are warm bodies. Let him show it on the] floor [of the House] because it’s easier said than done,” Defensor said in a phone interview.
But as if to underscore Villafuerte’s claim, three administration lawmakers -- Representatives Crispin Remulla of Cavite, Antonio Cerilles of Zamboanga del Sur, and Amado Bagatsing of Manila -- openly called for De Venecia’s resignation, citing what they called the Speaker’s poor leadership.
“134 signed the manifesto of loss of confidence [in De Venecia] and more are still signing,” the lawmaker said in a separate phone interview. The number of signatures is already more than the 121 needed to oust the Speaker, who can be unseated by a simple majority of the 240 members of the House.
Villafuerte said they would continue to gather more votes but not because they expected some lawmakers to withdraw their signature later on but to ensure superiority.
“Gusto lang namin talagang madagdagan yung bilang. Kahiyaan na yan kapag binawi pa nila. E pano kung i-publish namin yung signatures nila, mag one-page ad kami [We just want to add to the number. It would be embarrassing if they withdraw their signatures. What if we publish their signatures, come out with a one-page ad]?” he said.
However, Villafuerte said he would rather try to convince De Venecia to step down than bring the issue to the floor.
He said he was supposed to meet the Speaker Thursday but the meeting was cancelled because media had “preempted” the contents of the manifesto.
“Mag-uusap kami ni Speaker sa Monday dahil ang sabi niya noon, pakitaan lang siya ng [We will talk with the Speaker on Monday because said before to just show him] 121 signatures and he will step down. So we will present to him more than 121,” said the Kampi head.
“Sasabihin namin na, ‘O sabi mo, pag nakakita kami ng majority, you will step down o baka naman gusto mo pa ng bakbabakan sa floor [We will tell him, ‘You said, if we find a majority, you will step down, or maybe you want to slug it out on the floor]?’”
“I think he [De Venecia] should just step down. Ito na yung graceful exit na sinasabi. Huwag nang mag-resist [This is the graceful exit we were saying. Don’t try to resist], it will just be a futile, useless effort. Alam ng matatalo, gusto pang mabulgar [You already know you are a loser, you want to make a spectacle of it],” he said.
But Defensor said he would rather see things settled on the floor. “Paano kung bina-bluff lang niya kami? E di pinagtawanan kami ng mga tao [What if he is just bluffing us? People will laugh at us]. I stand by the position of my party. Hindi naman ako basta nagdedesisyon dahil lang sa sabi ng iba [I do not make decisions on the say-so of others]. I’m not gullible,” he said.
Deputy Speakers Simeon Datumanong of Maguindanao and Eric Singson of Ilocos Sur also reiterated their support for De Venecia.
But asked if he would withdraw his support if asked to by President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo, Datumanong said: “I’ll cross the bridge when we get there.”
Arroyo is Lakas chairman but also the founder of Kampi.
Although she gave orders last week to maintain the status quo in the House, moves to oust De Venecia have continued, with allies of the Speaker accusing Arroyo’s husband, Jose Miguel, and congressmen sons Juan Miguel of Pampanga and Diosdado of Camarines Sur, of being behind the plot.
Singson, for his part, said he would rather see the row resolved within the administration coalition than brought to a head on the floor.
“Ang sa akin [My position is], if there’s any move to remove him [de Venecia],hindi dapat ganun. Dapat merong [it shouldn’t be like this. There should be a] consensus among all the groups within the coalition,” he said in yet another phone interview.
“I don’t want the voting to be done. It will be very painful for both sides,” the lawmaker added.
Remulla said de Venecia would be doing a “heroic” gesture if he stepped down and nominate his successor.
"Speaker JDV's [De Venecia’s initials] favorite words are 'heroic' and 'historic.' I advise him to live up to those words by stepping down from the Speaker's chair and nominating a congressman from Mindanao to be the next Speaker," Remulla said in a statement.
Davao Representative Prospero Nograles is reportedly being eyed to replace De Venecia.
Remulla said the Speaker should make “the supreme sacrifice by giving way to defuse the tension in the House and keep it going so it can fully concentrate on serving our people.”
Bagatsing cited the alleged lack of transparency in dispensing House funds, the lack of reforms and De Venecia’s failure to discipline and prevent his son, Jose III, from supposedly maligning the President and her family, as the reasons for withdrawing his support for the Speaker.
"There are just too many House members who don't trust Mr. De Venecia now. If not now, when?" he said.
"JDV should now accept that his time has passed. He should step down now voluntarily before he is voted out of office," he stressed.
For his part, Cerilles noted the Speaker’s alleged inaction on a resolution unanimously passed by the chamber last year calling for an accounting of how House funds were being used.
"But to this day, no accounting has been done by Speaker De Venecia. Thus, there is now a widespread loss of confidence [in] his leadership among congressmen," the lawmaker said.
"He has to go," Cerilles added.