Another useless issue

[Monseratto]

Beside those hot babes singing the US anthem in the Pacquaio-Clottey fight being more interesting, the goverment is again making a hoot over the way the Philippine national anthem was sung.

Justice head: ‘Pineda’s rendition may have violated national anthem law’


MANILA, Philippines -- Journey vocalist Arnel Pineda may have violated the law with his stylized singing of the national anthem during the Pacquiao-Clottey fight last Saturday in Texas (Sunday in Manila), according to Justice Secretary Alberto Agra.

Agra, concurrent Solicitor General, said Republic Act 8491 clearly banned the singing or playing of “Lupang Hinirang” in any way other than the original musical arrangement made by composer Julian Felipe.

RA 8491 imposes a penalty of imprisonment of not more than one year or a fine of between P5,000 and P20,000.

Agra said he did not get to watch Pacquiao's latest fight so he could not say yet if Pineda violated the law, as the National Historical Institute (NHI) charged.

“In no uncertain terms the law is very categorical. Under our law we must follow the arrangement of Julian Felipe,” he said when asked for comment.

Should the NHI decide to pursue a case against Pineda to set an example to other singers who would be singing the national anthem in such a prominent event, Agra said government lawyers would have to settle the legal question of where to file the case since Pineda sang it in the United States.

“We are confronted with the issue of jurisdiction. I haven't been requested to issue a new (legal opinion on that),” Agra said.

[Horsepower]

Walang kwenta yung pagkanta ni Arnel ng Lupang Hinirang. Para syang hindi singer. He sounded amateur. Nagulat nga ako because he can sing well.

Para syang paos na puyat na may plema... weird isn't it?

-----

The good justice might have forgotten that we don't have jurisdiction over US soil (AFAIK). hehehehe.

[Altis6453]

Beside those hot babes singing the US anthem in the Pacquaio-Clottey fight being more interesting, the goverment is again making a hoot over the way the Philippine national anthem was sung.

I'd tell the NHI to kiss my a$$ and try to file a criminal case here for an "offense" which was supposedly done abroad. Our prosecutors would look pretty darn stupid.

[niky]

I'd tell the NHI to kiss my a$$ and try to file a criminal case here for an "offense" which was supposedly done abroad. Our prosecutors would look pretty darn stupid.

While they're at it, they can fine every singly choir that sings it... TV stations using it in their sing-offs (sung in a slower, more dramatic way than original)... and just about everyone else.

I'm sick to death of hearing about this issue, honestly.

[meledson]

kung may session ang senado. baka pag uusapan pa in session. "in aid of legislation"

[xoom]

yung trio nga na kumanta ng star spangled banner halos naka panty at bra na lang eh.

[falken]

Huwag na lang kanatahin ang "Lupang Hinirang" in all major events para walang problema. And the NHI can go F*ck themselves.

[Horsepower]

Yeah, the trio were so hot that star sprangled banner sounded so nice! hehehe.

[chua_riwap]

Walang kwenta yung pagkanta ni Arnel ng Lupang Hinirang. Para syang hindi singer. He sounded amateur. Nagulat nga ako because he can sing well.

Para syang paos na puyat na may plema... weird isn't it?

-----

The good justice might have forgotten that we don't have jurisdiction over US soil (AFAIK). hehehehe.

At...sa sobrang taas nung ginawa ni Pineda, muntik pang kinapos sa end nung anthem. Kung yung original melody na lang kasi ang sinusunod nila, wala na sanang problema. Binabago pa kasi.

Next time, kantahin na lang nila, "Pilipinas Kong Mahal".

[AnK]

bakit kasi kailangan pang bumirit eh, nabitin tuloy at pumiyok...

ang hilig kasi ng mga singers natin bumirit kahit wala sa lugar.

[Starex_Gold]

palagi naman ganyan. bawat may kakanta ng Lupang Hinirang sa laban ni Manny binabatikos.

gusto lang ng NHI pumapel para masabing may ginagawa sila. at sabi pa sa TV patrol, gusto na sumama ng NHI sa next fight ni Manny. epal diba :rofl: gusto lang siguro sumama para maka nood ng live

[Negus]

Yeah, the trio were so hot that star sprangled banner sounded so nice! hehehe.

posted video for emphasis.

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TjGj11IHpdg"]YouTube- The Star Spangled Banner - The Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders[/ame]



walang reklamo.

[napadpad_lang]

[SIZE=3]I just hope he stick to the original tempo, okay n asana ang 1st part, bakit pa kasi binirit niya yung huli… ung reaction ni Lito Camo dat was beside him was like wut duh “F” is he singing… panira, buti na lang panalo pa rin Manny at di nagging jinx ang kanta ni Arnel[/SIZE]

[frenchtower]

posted video for emphasis.

YouTube- The Star Spangled Banner - The Dallas Cowboy Cheerleaders



walang reklamo.

Can we get these Cowboy babes to sing the Philippine Anthem next time?

Or how about asking Pinay singers to wear really skimpy outfits while singing the Anthem? That will surely be a treat

[redorange]

How do you prosecute someone for doing something against Philippine law if the act didn't happen in the Philippines? Last I checked Dallas is in the US the Philippine law does not apply worldwide just in the Philippines. Sad that the DOJ Secretary doesn't know where his jurisdiction begins and ends. For all the crying that the NHI has done every time Pacman has a fight how many singers has actually been prosecuted or fined? Zero, none, wala..because they can't enforce Philippine law to an event that happened abroad.

[bluerolla]

Malamang wala ng maglalakas loob na kumanta sa susunod

Bakit di kaya someone from NHI ang kumanta para wala na sila masabi...

[vito corleone]

yung trio nga na kumanta ng star spangled banner halos naka panty at bra na lang eh

the belt was actually more than half of the total length of their short pants. . .yeah, one of the best scenes in that fight, the other one when pacman gave clottey a pompyang. . .pilyo si pacman

[vito corleone]

Bakit di kaya someone from NHI ang kumanta para wala na sila masabi...

nice "suggestment"

[OldSchoolHack]

Kung ikinanta ang Lupang Hinirang sa tamang paraan as NHI wanted......

Nobody can actually sing it properly. It is a fast beat marching song. Binagalan na yan nuong unang panahon dahil nga hindi makanta.

Aptly titled thread.

[foresterx]

papapansin lang ang NHI, mga wala kasi magawa kaya ng gugulo na lang.