Ford Ranger XLT M/T vs. Montero Sport GLX M/T

[Ian Villanueva]

Hi all,

Long time member here, forgot my login details so logged in with Facebook. Haha. Anyway, upgrading my current 2010 Honda Jazz to a bigger car worth around Php1.1M.

Initially, I was only eyeing the Ford Ranger XLT since they price point was within budget, and it was one of the cheaper big cars that I really liked. I was ready to get it. But lo and behold, I found out that the Montero GLX M/T is almost exactly the same price point when you take into consideration the SRP discount and the insurance, LTO and other freebies which Ford can not offer.

Montero SRP is at 1.203M vs Ranger at 1.079M. But after discounts, they basically have almost the exact same cashout.

For a daily drive, which would you choose? Main considerations are:

1. Ride comfort
2. Fuel efficiency
3. Maintenance cost
4. Looks

I don't really need a pickup since I might only haul stuff 4/5 times a year, but I love the ride height and the sheer size of the Ranger. I love the interior as well, since it looks refined and it doesn't feel like you're driving a truck when you're inside. I'm worried about its longevity though, both in appeal and practical use, especially as I will be turning 30 in two years. Baka hindi na bagay ang pick-up sa corporate setting. Hehe

I like the Montero since it looks elegant and sporty at the same time. It can be used both in a corporate and rugged setting. I think its appeal can last for years as well, since it's your basic big SUV. However, the interior looks dull compared to the Ranger, and from the reviews I've been reading, I think the Ranger wins in fuel efficiency.

I have yet to test drive both, since apparently they don't have test drive units of the Ranger. Will test drive the Montero this week.

Which would you guys pick, all things considered? I'm single, by the way. No plans of having a family within the next 5 years. :D

[niky]

Single? You driving? Get the Ranger.

The Montero has more seats and a more comfortable ride, but the Ranger has better steering, better handling, better braking and a more rugged underchassis and suspension. It also has better flood fording capability. The 2.2 has decent economy and if you're worried about your stuff getting wet, weather protection is just a roller cover or camper shell away.

[ray_noel]

Does ford ranger XL 4x2 is a goodbuy? I saw the price is only at 857k compared to trend a/t ecosport its 875k, which of the two is more better for its price?

Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[leodawesome]

Maintenance Cost = Non-VGT Montero

Looks = Ranger - Regardless if corporate or rugged

Single = Ranger

Extra Seats and Roof = Non-VGT Montero - The 7 seater montero is flexible when space is needed. You can just fold the 3rd row seats, whereas in pickups, you need something to cover stuff at the bed.

Engine = Ranger

[Jim Cainglet]

I would prefer a montero sir, with your kind of setting especially in corporate life and city driving.

Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[jut703]

I have a Ranger and I'm also in corporate but I think it's not that out of place.

It's actually a great car for a single guy, though admittedly I find myself frequently wishing for an enclosed cargo area. This could be easily solved with a 25k roller lid though.

While the Ranger is great to drive if it's just you, the Montero is a more comfortable car for passengers.

If you're not looking for power and don't mind the Montero's docile looks, go for it. It's really the better all-rounder.

But if you want a tough-as-nails brute that looks stunning and is still feature-rich, then go for the Ranger. It's not for all, but who knows, it might suit you well.


Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[jaymd]

monty for me. mainly because of convenience... pick ups are harder to park because of its bigger turning radius long tailgate and in the rangers case its a BIG and wide pickup. maintenance baka mas mura monty. Isa pa ... pangit gawing trunk yun pick up bed. pag roller lid nag leak din yun. yun fiberglass cover naman di ka maka load ng mataas na gamit kasi flat lang sya. ok pa yun nabibili na bolt on trunk sa likod kaso maiinitan din gamit mo lalo na kung groceries or other perishable items

[TholitzReloaded]

Using Ranger for Daily drive, performance wise hands down, looks - head turner, di naman ganun kahirap i park depends on the kind of parking area you have.

[Ian Villanueva]

Thanks guys!! Previously replied to this thread but I don't know why my reply got deleted. Test drove both over the weekend. Now I'm super torn!!

Ranger:
+ Has that king-of-the-road feel, especially with that height and sheer size. The only cars that matched its size are the land cruisers and the Prados
+ super refined and quiet interior
+ Floods won't be a problem
+ BAD A*S

- quiet bouncy, but tolerable
- not much use for the flat bed

Montero:
+ Comfortable ride and spacious interior given the additional space for the seats
+ Safe choice, family-ready
+ Looks okay even in stock form, refined

- People say it looks daddy-ish for a young, single guy
- Just a bit noisier than the Ranger
- No use for the 7 seats as well since I will be driving solo most of the time
- looks just okay, no wow factor unlike the Ranger

Now what? Haha. I keep on telling myself either of the two is a good choice. Maybe 7 out of 10 people I asked picked the Ranger, saying it's newer and the Montero is due for a new model soon. Heck I wish I could have both. Help!

[SiRbossR]

Just get yourself a Ranger.

[TholitzReloaded]

Thanks guys!! Previously replied to this thread but I don't know why my reply got deleted. Test drove both over the weekend. Now I'm super torn!!

Ranger:
+ Has that king-of-the-road feel, especially with that height and sheer size. The only cars that matched its size are the land cruisers and the Prados
+ super refined and quiet interior
+ Floods won't be a problem
+ BAD A*S

- quiet bouncy, but tolerable
- not much use for the flat bed

Montero:
+ Comfortable ride and spacious interior given the additional space for the seats
+ Safe choice, family-ready
+ Looks okay even in stock form, refined

- People say it looks daddy-ish for a young, single guy
- Just a bit noisier than the Ranger
- No use for the 7 seats as well since I will be driving solo most of the time
- looks just okay, no wow factor unlike the Ranger

Now what? Haha. I keep on telling myself either of the two is a good choice. Maybe 7 out of 10 people I asked picked the Ranger, saying it's newer and the Montero is due for a new model soon. Heck I wish I could have both. Help!

what happened kaya did you get a Ranger or a Montero? any updates?

[jut703]

Ranger. You don't seem to need the added utility of the Montero.

Then, just get yourself a sliding cover for the rear bed so you can put bags or whatever sturdy cargo you have.


Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[3GEMS]

Get the blue ranger bro, mukha na luma ang montero, , you'll get the 7 seaters montero for what? Hangang single kapa samantalahin mo na pagkakataon, once na may asawa kana and may bata na, mag iiba na mindset mo and for sure mas marami kang mases*x sa ranger hahaha!!!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[cokyi]

Get the blue ranger bro, mukha na luma ang montero, , you'll get the 7 seaters montero for what? Hangang single kapa samantalahin mo na pagkakataon, once na may asawa kana and may bata na, mag iiba na mindset mo and for sure mas marami kang mases*x sa ranger hahaha!!!


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

HAHAHAHA that's what I'm talking about. Pang-chicks ang labanan. Haha! Yan din sabi ng mga tao, baka mag-all-new Montero na, but I doubt it kasi 2008 pa lang ata yung current. The Fortuner started around 2005-2006 and it's still the same model.

Choosing between a white Montero vs. a Black/White Ranger XLT!

[leodawesome]

Baka sir bigla kang maging married with dependents with the ranger

[cokyi]

Baka sir bigla kang maging married with dependents with the ranger

Yun lang. Biglang kailanganin ng Monty just because of the Ranger. Haha! Madalas actually pag guys ang tinatanong, 80% Ranger ang pipiliin. Pag girl, half-half. :p

[leodawesome]

Yun lang. Biglang kailanganin ng Monty just because of the Ranger. Haha! Madalas actually pag guys ang tinatanong, 80% Ranger ang pipiliin. Pag girl, half-half. :p

The montero doesn't really give you the 'old dad' image, unlike the Alterra or the crosswinds (peace to owners :D ). Its actually quite appealing for a single guy. But if you want brusko appeal, then it really is the ranger for you. Just a sidenote, there are 5 ranger XLTs here in the office parking.

If I were in your shoes, I'd get the ranger. Even if you do have a family for the next 3-5 years, you can still fit your wife, 2 kids and a yaya in it. Just like what others said, you can buy something that can cover stuff at the bed. The montero is a safe and practical choice, but I know there's a reason why you did an apples-to-oranges comparison of it with the ranger, aside from the pricetag. To me it seems that the ranger is really your first choice but just picked the montero for practicality and for the 'norm'.

Do yourself a favor and get rid of this dilemma. Go get yourself a ranger.

[erl919]

oh late ko na nabasa... will add some since we have both ranger and montero.

Congrats enjoy your ride.

Posted via Tsikot Mobile App

[glenn manikis]

Payong? Sa side door pockets.. All 4 doors kasya ang payong... SA may likod ng sandalan sa rear seats... Dun din nakalagay laptop bag ko... Kung mahaba naman ang payong mo sa may likod ng headrest ng rear seats...

Sent from my C2305 using Tsikot Forums mobile app